01
Best overall pick
Table Rock Brick Oven Pizza
Berlin, About 10 Minutes South • Brick-Oven New York-Style Pizzeria • Best Overall Pick
Crisp, chewy brick-oven crust and generous toppings make this Berlin spot the go-to splurge from Mount Hope.
Table Rock feels a bit more polished than most small-town pizza shops, with a proper brick oven turning out pies that have real texture and char. Toppings lean classic but are thoughtfully done, and the salads are better than you might expect, which helps when you’re feeding a group. It is an easy choice after a day poking around the Berlin shops or on your way back through Mount Hope.
02
Small-town gem
Charm Pizza Co.
Charm, Just South Of Mount Hope • Buffet-Style Hometown Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Families
A low-key buffet with rotating pies, this Charm favorite is built for casual gatherings and hungry families.
Charm Pizza Co. feels exactly like the kind of small-town place where locals linger after ball games or Sunday evenings. The buffet setup means you can sample several topping combinations without overthinking your order, and kids can go back for that one slice they liked best. It is an easy, no-pressure stop when you want plenty of food and a relaxed pace a few minutes from Mount Hope.
03
Destination pizza
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek, Easy Drive East • Creative, Farm-Inspired Pizza Kitchen • Worth-The-Drive Option
Thoughtful toppings and a from-scratch approach make Park Street the place you brag about finding back home.
Park Street Pizza has a loyal following for its crust and toppings that lean a little more chef-driven than most rural spots. Expect combinations that spotlight local produce and meats alongside more traditional choices, all done with noticeable attention to detail. It is a bit of a drive from Mount Hope, but many locals consider it their “special pizza night” pick for good reason.
04
Reliable classic
East of Chicago Pizza
Millersburg, Holmes County Seat • Classic Midwest Pizza Chain Shop • Best For Easy Takeout
Thick, cheesy pies and familiar flavors make this Millersburg shop a dependable choice when you just want pizza fast.
East of Chicago in Millersburg leans into hearty, comfort-style pizza with plenty of cheese and a sturdy crust. The menu is broad, with wings, subs, and sides that cover most tastes, and online ordering keeps things simple on busy nights. It is the kind of place Holmes County residents rely on for last-minute takeout runs from Mount Hope and the surrounding townships.
05
Familiar favorite
Pizza Hut
Millersburg, Main Commercial Strip • Sit-Down National Pizza Restaurant • Post-Game And Road-Trip Stop
A classic dine-in Pizza Hut that still delivers the pan pizza and breadsticks many grew up with.
Millersburg’s Pizza Hut is a practical option when you have a car full of kids or a group that just wants something predictable. The sit-down setup works well for teams and large families, and the menu of pan pizzas, pasta, and wings is as straightforward as it gets. For visitors coming through Mount Hope who crave something familiar after a long day on the road, it hits the spot.