01
Best classic Ohio Valley slice
DiCarlo's Pizza
Downtown Yorkville • Classic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Old-School Local Legend
A must-try if you want the original Ohio Valley square-cut experience just down the hill from Mount Pleasant.
DiCarlo's is the place locals point to when they talk about true Ohio Valley pizza: a thin, crispy square-cut crust baked with sauce, then finished with a blanket of freshly added cheese and toppings right out of the oven. It is a simple, no-frills counter-service spot, so expect to grab a box and go rather than linger over a long meal. From Mount Pleasant, it is an easy drive to Yorkville when the craving for that distinctive style hits.
02
Best specialty pies
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Martins Ferry Riverfront • Neighborhood Delivery And Carryout Joint • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
A go-to for hefty, topping-loaded pies and thick, chewy crust within a short drive of the village.
DeFelice Bros. serves the kind of hearty, generously topped pizzas that work for feeding a crowd after ballgames or family get-togethers. The crust has some chew, the sauce leans classic and slightly sweet, and the specialty combinations are the draw, from meat-heavy options to veggie-focused pies. Call ahead from Mount Pleasant and your order is usually ready by the time you get down to Martins Ferry.
03
Best sit-down experience
Giovanni's Pizza
National Road In St. Clairsville • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
Family-friendly Italian spot where you can pair a solid pie with pasta, salads, and a relaxed sit-down meal.
Giovanni's offers a full-service experience if you want more than just a quick slice, with pizzas, pastas, salads, and appetizers under one roof. The pizzas skew classic Midwestern style, with a balanced crust and plenty of cheese, and you can easily build your own or choose from house combinations. It is a good choice when you are coming into St. Clairsville for errands and want to sit down and make a night of it rather than just grabbing takeout.
04
Best familiar dine-in chain
Pizza Hut
St. Clairsville Retail Corridor • Casual Chain Pizzeria With Dine-In • Best For Families And Picky Eaters
A dependable stop for pan pizza, wings, and breadsticks in a sit-down setting that everyone in the group will recognize.
The St. Clairsville Pizza Hut is a classic option when you need crowd-pleasing pizza with no surprises, whether that means thick pan crust, stuffed crust, or a basic thin round. Families appreciate the easy parking, familiar menu, and kid-friendly booths, especially if they are already out near the mall or big-box stores. It is not trying to be gourmet, but when you want comfortingly predictable pizza and sides, it gets the job done.
05
Best fast delivery option
Domino's Pizza
Central St. Clairsville • Delivery-Focused National Chain • Fast, Familiar Option
The choice when speed, late hours, and easy online ordering matter more than hunting down a hidden gem.
Domino's in St. Clairsville leans into speed and convenience, with reliable app and online ordering, regular deals, and a wide range of crusts and sauces. It is a solid pick for late-night cravings, game-day deliveries, or those nights when nobody wants to cook and you just want pizza to show up at the door. If you are staying near the interstate or in town for shopping, it is often the quickest way to get a hot pie without much planning.