01
Small-town staple
Larry's Pizza & Wings
Downtown Mount Sterling • Small-Town Pizza And Wings Joint • Best Overall Pick
The local go-to for generous pies, plenty of toppings, and no-fuss comfort food right in the heart of Mount Sterling.
Larry's is the spot most locals name first when you ask where to get pizza in Mount Sterling. The crust leans classic Midwestern, with edge-to-edge toppings and lots of cheese, and the menu backs it up with wings, subs, and other game-night staples. It’s casual, friendly, and exactly the kind of place where staff remember regulars’ favorite orders.
02
London classic
Ronetti's Pizza
Downtown London • Classic Family Pizza Parlor • Best Small-Town Classic
A long-running London favorite serving square-cut pies that feel tailor-made for sharing with a table full of friends.
About a 15-minute drive from Mount Sterling, Ronetti's delivers the kind of no-trend, no-gimmick pizza that keeps regulars coming back decade after decade. Expect a slightly crisp crust, well-seasoned sauce, and that classic Central Ohio square cut that makes it easy to feed a crowd. The laid-back dining room and hometown service make it a comfortable stop after ballgames or errands in London.
03
Go-to for big groups
Phat Daddy's Pizza
East London • Carryout-Focused Pizzeria With Big Portions • Best For Game Nights
Hearty, topping-loaded pizzas, wings, and sides that are built for feeding hungry families and teams.
Phat Daddy's is a smart choice when you need lots of pizza without overcomplicating things. The menu leans into crowd-pleasers—think meat-loaded specialties, cheesy garlic bread, and wings that travel well for carryout. It’s a convenient stop off the main routes through London and an easy add to any Friday-night rotation for Mount Sterling residents.
04
Historic tavern pick
Plank's On Broadway
Historic Downtown Grove City • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizza House • Worth-The-Drive Tavern Pie
A Grove City institution known for its slightly sweet Columbus-style crust and generous, edge-to-edge toppings.
Set on Grove City’s main drag, Plank's On Broadway feels like a throwback in the best possible way. The thin, tavern-style crust and square-cut slices are perfect with a cold drink, and the toppings are layered right to the edge so every bite counts. It’s a bit of a drive from Mount Sterling, but many locals happily make the trip when they’re craving a classic bar pizza experience.
05
Family-night favorite
Tammy's Pizza
Grove City Town Center Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza Shop With Hearty Crusts • Best For Families
Comforting, thick-crust pies and friendly service make this Grove City staple an easy choice for family dinners.
Tammy's Pizza serves the kind of hefty, cheese-laden pies that feel built for sharing around a busy kitchen table. Crusts are sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, and the menu stretches into subs, salads, and sides so everyone can find something. For Mount Sterling folks combining a trip to Columbus’ southwest side with dinner, it’s a relaxed, dependable option.