01
Closest go-to from Murray City
Valley Pizza Co.
New Straitsville, North Of Murray City • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Quick Carryout
A cozy New Straitsville standby turning out generously topped, classic pies that travelers and locals grab on their way through the valley.
If you’re in Murray City and want pizza without a long drive, Valley Pizza Co. is usually the first name locals mention. The menu leans classic—think well-loaded pepperoni, meat lovers, and simple veggie combinations—done with a reliably crisp crust and plenty of cheese. Call ahead on busy evenings; the shop is small and gets a steady rush from nearby towns.
02
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Logan, Along Oh-33 • Family-Friendly Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Logan institution known for hefty toppings, shareable specialty pies, and a steady crowd of regulars.
Pizza Crossing is the spot many Hocking County residents will gladly drive for, thanks to its thick blanket of cheese and toppings that run right to the edge. Specialty pizzas, from classic deluxe combinations to loaded chicken options, make it easy to feed a mixed group. Dine in after a day in Hocking Hills or order ahead for pickup on your way back to Murray City.
03
Most creative pies
Avalanche Pizza
Athens, Near Ohio University • Creative Artisan Pie Shop • Worth-The-Drive Destination
An Athens favorite turning out inventive, big-flavor pizzas with house-made dough and bold toppings.
Avalanche Pizza is where you go when you want something beyond pepperoni and cheese. Expect chewy, flavorful crusts, interesting sauce options, and topping combinations that range from Mediterranean-inspired to spicy, smoky creations. It’s a bit of a drive from Murray City, but many people pair it with a trip to Athens or Hocking Hills and consider the detour part of the fun.
04
Best for a casual night out
Courtside Pizza
Athens, Court Street • Lively College-Town Pizza Bar • Best For Groups And Game Nights
Thin, foldable slices and cold drinks served in a buzzing downtown Athens setting steps from the college crowd.
Courtside Pizza has a straightforward formula: crisp-edged, New York–style slices, pitchers, and plenty of energy, especially on weekends and game days. It’s a relaxed place to split a large pie after a stroll through Athens or a visit to Ohio University. From Murray City, it makes the most sense when you’re already in town, but it’s a dependable stop if you like a lively atmosphere with your pizza.
05
Reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Nelsonville, Just Off Us-33 • National Chain Carryout And Dine-In • Reliable Backup Option
A familiar stop in Nelsonville for classic chain pizzas, breadsticks, and quick family meals.
When you want something predictable and easy to order, the Nelsonville Pizza Hut fits the bill. The menu is the same one you’ll recognize anywhere—pan pizzas, stuffed crust, wings, and pasta—making it an easy choice for families with picky eaters. It’s an uncomplicated option if you’re passing through Nelsonville or need a straightforward takeout stop on the way back to Murray City.