01
Best overall pick
Creno’s Pizza Nashport
Along Frazeysburg Road In Nashport • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To Local Classic
Creno’s in Nashport turns out generous, cheesy pies that taste exactly like a Friday night at home should.
This is the spot many Nashport locals call first when someone says “let’s just order a pizza.” The crust runs on the slightly thicker side, with plenty of cheese and classic toppings that hit the comfort-food sweet spot. Round it out with wings, subs, and breadsticks and you’ve got an easy crowd-pleaser without driving into town.
02
Classic sit-down choice
Adornetto’s Pizzeria & House of Pasta
Downtown Zanesville • Old-School Italian Pizza Parlor • Best For Lingering Over A Meal
Adornetto’s is a Zanesville institution, known for its saucy pies, big portions, and nostalgic red-sauce-Italian vibe.
If you want more of a night out than a quick pickup, Adornetto’s is the move. Their pizzas come with a slightly sweet, hearty sauce, plenty of cheese, and a choice of classic or loaded toppings, plus a full menu of pastas and Italian mains. It’s the kind of place where families gather after games and locals bring out-of-town guests to show off a bit of Zanesville history.
03
Family-friendly favorite
Pizza Cottage Zanesville
North Zanesville Near Maple Avenue Shopping • Casual Family Pizza Restaurant • Best For Families And Teams
Pizza Cottage serves big, shareable pies with lots of topping combinations, plus salads and subs to keep the whole table happy.
Set near the main shopping strip, this is a practical stop when you’ve got a car full of kids or a whole team to feed after practice. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and thick, with edge-to-edge toppings and specialty combinations like loaded meat or veggie pies. Spacious seating and a laid-back atmosphere make it easy to stretch out and stay awhile.
04
Best pizza with a pint
Weasel Boy Brewing Company
Riverside Zanesville Near The Y-Bridge • Craft Brewery With Artisan Pizza • Top Pick For Craft Beer Fans
Weasel Boy pairs small-batch beer with hand-tossed pizzas topped more like a gastropub than a corner shop.
Come here when you want your pizza night to feel like an evening out, not just a meal. The pies lean toward thinner, flavorful crusts with toppings that go beyond the basics—think specialty meats, roasted veggies, and house blends that play well with their rotating taps. Add live music nights and a view of the river, and it’s an easy choice for date night or meeting friends.
05
Reliable delivery option
Donatos Pizza Zanesville
East Zanesville • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain Shop • Best For Fast Delivery And Carryout
Donatos is known for its ultra-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, making it a dependable choice when you need dinner on the doorstep.
When you’re short on time or feeding a mix of picky eaters, Donatos is tough to beat. The signature thin crust stays crisp under generous toppings, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to lighter veggie pies and boneless wings. It’s a straightforward, no-surprises option that delivers consistently hot, accurate orders out toward Nashport.