01
Closest classic pie
Pizza Parlor
Downtown Millersburg • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Closest Sit-Down Option
A no-frills Millersburg staple turning out reliably good, traditional pizzas in a cozy small-town setting.
If you live in or around Nashville, Pizza Parlor in Millersburg is often the easiest answer to “Where should we grab a pizza tonight?”. Expect classic Midwest-style pies with plenty of cheese, friendly service, and a dining room that feels like it has hosted generations of local teams and birthday parties. It is the kind of spot where they remember regulars and keep the toppings list straightforward but satisfying.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
Near Mohican State Park In Loudonville • Family-Friendly Buffet-Style Pizzeria • Best For Teams And Families
A crowd-pleasing stop in Loudonville with thick-crust pies, buffet options, and plenty of room for groups coming off the river or trails.
Head west to Loudonville and you will hit East of Chicago, a familiar name that locals lean on after a day at Mohican. The menu leans hearty, with thick and pan-style crusts, lots of toppings, and a salad bar or buffet depending on the day. It is a natural fit for ball teams, youth groups, or extended families who want to sit together, refuel, and not overthink the order.
03
Most reliable carryout
East of Chicago Pizza
East Millersburg Corridor • Takeout-Focused Regional Chain • Best Quick Carryout
A dependable Millersburg outpost with familiar crusts, customizable toppings, and easy carryout or delivery into the countryside.
For nights when you want pizza without a sit-down stop, the Millersburg East of Chicago is a practical go-to. The menu covers the bases with build-your-own pies, classic specialty combinations, and extras like breadsticks and wings to round out a meal. It is especially handy if you are staying in a cabin, rental, or farmhouse and want something everyone will recognize and share.
04
Best overall pick
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Rustic, Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Destination Pizza Night
A destination-worthy Sugarcreek spot known for quality ingredients, creative combinations, and a warm small-town atmosphere.
Park Street Pizza is the place many locals are happy to drive for, thanks to its emphasis on fresh ingredients and thoughtfully built pies. The menu often showcases local produce and meats, and you can taste the difference in everything from the crust to the toppings. Combine a visit with a day in Sugarcreek and you have an easy, very satisfying pizza night out from Nashville.
05
Worth-the-drive icon
Coccia House
Downtown Wooster • Retro Italian-American Pizza Tavern • Iconic Regional Favorite
A Wooster institution serving generously topped, distinctive pies in a throwback dining room that draws loyal fans from all over the region.
If you are willing to make a slightly longer drive, Coccia House in Wooster is the kind of old-school pizza joint people talk about for years. The pies come loaded with toppings, a distinctive crust, and that slightly messy, fork-and-knife character that defines Midwest comfort pizza. The dining room is cozy and a bit nostalgic, making it a fun outing when you want your pizza night to feel like an occasion.