01
Best overall pick
Crust Pizzeria
Whitehouse • Modern Neighborhood Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Thoughtfully made pies, crisp crusts, and reliable service make Crust the go-to stop when Neapolis locals crave a proper pizza night.
In nearby Whitehouse, Crust Pizzeria leans into simple ingredients and well-balanced toppings rather than gimmicks. The crust lives up to the name—lightly chewy with a good char, sturdy enough for generous cheese and meat combos. It’s a comfortable, come-as-you-are spot that works just as well for a midweek takeout order as it does for a relaxed dinner after a day on the road.
02
Best tavern pie
Log Cabin Tavern
Liberty Center • Laid-Back Tavern And Pizza Spot • Best For Groups
A short country drive from Neapolis, this rustic tavern turns out crowd-pleasing pizzas alongside cold drinks and friendly small-town service.
Log Cabin Tavern feels like the kind of place you stumble on once and then keep returning to. The pizza is classic tavern style—plenty of cheese, a crust with some bite, and topping combinations built to share around a big table. It’s an easy pick when you’ve got a mixed group looking for wings, burgers, and a couple of big pies in one relaxed spot.
03
For deep-dish cravings
PizzaPapalis
Downtown Toledo • Casual Deep-Dish And Pizza Restaurant • Destination Pick
If you’re willing to make the 30–40 minute run into Toledo, PizzaPapalis rewards the drive with hefty, shareable deep-dish pies.
Known regionally for its Chicago-style deep dish, PizzaPapalis is where Neapolis folks go when they want a pizza that eats more like a full-on meal. The thick, buttery crust and generous layers of cheese and sauce are ideal for lingering over with a group. It’s not an every-week stop, but when the craving hits, this is the spot that justifies the extra miles.
04
Best wood-fired option
ZaZa Wood Fired Pizza
Toledo West Side • Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
ZaZa focuses on thin, blistered crusts and thoughtful toppings, giving Neapolis diners a more modern, wood-fired alternative to tavern pies.
Set on Toledo’s west side, ZaZa Wood Fired Pizza trades heavy, piled-on slices for airy crusts with a good char and fresh toppings. It’s a natural choice when you want something a little more polished—think a shared margherita, a salad, and a drink instead of a basic delivery order. For Neapolis residents, it makes a nice upgrade stop when you’re already heading into the city for an evening out.
05
Reliable family choice
Rastelli's Pizza
Swanton • Family-Friendly Pizza Shop • Best For Families
Rastelli's in nearby Swanton offers straightforward, satisfying pies that are easy to split with kids or a hungry crew.
This Swanton mainstay leans classic: familiar toppings, fair prices, and pizzas that hold up on the ride back to Neapolis. The crust is sturdy without being heavy, and the menu has enough variety—subs, sides, and more—that everyone can find something. It’s the kind of dependable, no-drama spot you keep in your back pocket for Friday nights and casual get-togethers.