01
Best overall pick
R' Pizza Place
Historic Columbiana • Made-From-Scratch Family Pizzeria • Local Favorite For A Sit-Down Pie
A cozy Columbiana standby known for scratch-made dough, generous toppings, and friendly, small-town service.
If you only make one pizza stop away from Negley, R' Pizza Place is the one that locals will nudge you toward. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with plenty of edge for people who like a good, browned rim. Go classic with pepperoni and banana peppers, or split the table-friendly specialty pies and a salad for a relaxed, linger-over-dinner night.
02
Best small-town classic
Pizza Joe's
East Palestine Village Center • Casual Small-Chain Pizzeria • Game-Night And Kids’ Party Go-To
A familiar regional name turning out crowd-pleasing pizzas, wedgies, and wings just a short hop from Negley.
Pizza Joe's in East Palestine is the reliable choice when you need to feed a group without overthinking it. The pies lean saucy and cheesy, with a soft, slightly thick crust that travels well in the box. Pair a couple of large specialty pizzas with an order of wings or a wedgie sandwich, and you have an easy solution for ballgame nights or birthday gatherings.
03
Closest quick-stop option
Fox's Pizza Den
New Waterford Crossroads • Carry-Out And Delivery Shop • Closest To Negley For Fast Takeout
A no-frills Fox’s outpost that focuses on hot pies, strombolis, and grinders to grab on your way through town.
For Negley residents, Fox's Pizza Den in nearby New Waterford is often the most convenient choice for a last-minute pizza run. The menu leans heavily into hearty options—think thick-cut toppings, baked subs, and loaded strombolis that can stand in for a full meal. It’s the kind of place where you call in an order, swing through the lot, and get home with still-steaming boxes in under half an hour.
04
Best for big appetites
Adrian's Pizza
Calcutta Shopping Strip • Hearty Pizza And Wings Joint • Best For Groups And Game Days
A Calcutta favorite turning out big, cheesy pies and shareable appetizers ideal for hungry families and friend groups.
Adrian's Pizza, up on the Calcutta strip, is built for nights when everyone shows up hungry. Pizzas come piled high with toppings, and the wing and appetizer lineup makes it easy to fill the table without breaking the bank. It’s especially popular on Friday and Saturday evenings, when families mix with sports fans catching a game over a spread of pepperoni pizza and hot wings.
05
Best value carry-out
Gionino's Pizzeria
Hilltop Calcutta Area • Crust-Forward Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best Value For Everyday Pizza Night
A carry-out favorite known for its garlicky crust, generous cheese, and combo deals that make weeknight pizza affordable.
Gionino's in Calcutta is the spot locals mention when you ask where to get a solid pie at a good price. The crust is the star here—chewy with a distinct garlicky edge—topped with plenty of cheese and straightforward, familiar toppings. Watch the specials board, bundle a couple of larges with chicken or JoJo potatoes, and you can feed a household without stretching the budget.