01
Best overall pick
Pizza Point
Warsaw Village Center • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The go-to slice spot in Warsaw, with solid crust, generous toppings, and fair prices.
Just a short drive from Nellie, Pizza Point feels like the village living room, with steady takeout traffic and families popping in for dinner. The pizzas lean hearty rather than fussy—think well-browned cheese, plenty of pepperoni, and a crust that holds up on the ride home. It’s the kind of place you trust for last‑minute game-night orders or a no‑drama Friday night meal.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
South Side Of Warsaw • Casual Buffet-Style Chain Pizzeria • Great For Families And Teams
A reliable choice when you need pan pizzas, breadsticks, and plenty of room for a crew.
East of Chicago in Warsaw is built for groups, with big pans of pizza, wings, and sides that make feeding a crowd straightforward. Their trademark pan crust is thick, buttery, and especially good under heavier toppings. It’s an easy option after youth games, church events, or whenever you want a spread that everyone—from picky kids to hungry coaches—can agree on.
03
Best small-town sit-down
Crowtown Pizza
Downtown Coshocton • Sit-Down Pizzeria And Italian Spot • Cozy Dine-In Pick
A warmly run Coshocton staple with thoughtfully made pizzas and a comfortable dining room.
Crowtown Pizza is the kind of place where you linger over a pie instead of rushing out the door. The crust has a nice chew, the toppings are balanced rather than overloaded, and the menu includes a few pasta and salad options if someone in the group isn’t in a pizza mood. Pair it with a stroll through downtown Coshocton and you have an easy, low-key night out from Nellie.
04
Best for loaded specialty pies
Plus 1 Pizza
Walnut Street In Coshocton • Neighborhood Delivery And Carryout Shop • Top Specialty Pizza Choice
Known for generously topped specialty pizzas that travel well back to Nellie and the surrounding countryside.
Plus 1 Pizza leans into creative combinations and heavy-handed toppings, making it a favorite for people who like their pies fully loaded. The crust is sturdy enough to handle it, so even delivery orders arrive in good shape. It’s a smart call when you want something a bit more interesting than plain pepperoni—think meat-heavy options, veggie-forward pies, and plenty of add-ons.
05
Most reliable late-night option
Domino's Pizza
Commercial Strip Near Us-36 In Coshocton • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
The familiar chain that shines for fast, predictable delivery when other kitchens are closed.
For those nights when it’s getting late and you just want hot pizza to show up at the door, the Coshocton Domino’s is tough to beat. Online ordering and tracking make it easy to time a delivery out toward Nellie or nearby campgrounds. Stick with your favorite combination or mix in wings, pasta, and desserts for a full, low-effort spread.