01
Best overall pick
Baker's Pizza Sports Shack
Downtown Bucyrus • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Go-To Local Hangout For Pizza And Games
A bustling Bucyrus favorite where generous pies meet plenty of TVs and cold drinks.
If you want a true small-town Ohio pizza experience, Baker's is the place locals name first. The crust is sturdy enough for loaded toppings, and the specialty combinations are made to go with a game on the big screens. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a crowd that wants pizza, wings, and a fun, noisy room.
02
Top choice for thick crust
East of Chicago Pizza
Upper Sandusky East Side • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Hearty, Shareable Pies
Known for its thick, doughy crust and generous toppings, this is the spot when you want a filling pie to-go.
The Upper Sandusky East of Chicago is a reliable stop when you’re headed back toward Nevada and want pizza ready to unpack at home. Their signature thick crust and loaded specialty pizzas are ideal for feeding a hungry family or a post-game crew. Order ahead, grab some breadsticks and a salad, and you’re set for an easy dinner.
03
Classic dine-in experience
Pizza Hut
Upper Sandusky Shopping Strip • Family-Friendly Dine-In Chain • Best For Familiar Comfort Pizza
A sit-down option where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and salad bar-style sides make for an easy family night out.
For many locals, this Pizza Hut is where kids’ teams celebrate and families meet up after errands in town. The classic pan and stuffed-crust pizzas deliver that nostalgic chain-pizza taste, and the menu keeps everyone at the table happy. It’s an especially good pick when you’d rather linger in a booth than hurry home with a box.
04
Fastest delivery option
Domino's Pizza
Bucyrus South Side • Quick-Delivery Pizza Chain • Best Late-Night And Game-Day Delivery
Domino’s in Bucyrus is the dependable choice when you want hot pizza delivered fast toward the Nevada side of the county.
When the craving hits late or you’re settled in for a big game, this Domino’s is all about speed and consistency. The menu leans into build-your-own pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, so everyone can call their own order. It’s especially handy for Nevada residents who don’t feel like making the drive and just want a reliable box at the door.
05
Best customizable pies
Marco's Pizza
North Marion • Takeout-Focused Pizza Chain • Best For Made-To-Order Flavor Combos
A popular Marion stop where you can customize sauces, crusts, and toppings for a more tailored chain-pizza experience.
If you’re already heading down to Marion for shopping or errands, Marco’s is an easy add to the route. The draw here is the ability to fine-tune your order, from the type of crust to extra-seasoned edges and specialty sauces. Grab a couple of their specialty pies and cheesy bread, and the drive back toward Nevada suddenly feels a lot shorter.