01
Essential Ohio Valley classic
DiCarlo's Original Pizza - Wintersville
Wintersville • Classic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Local Icon
The Wintersville DiCarlo’s is the go-to stop for that unmistakable Ohio Valley square pizza with cheese sprinkled on after the bake.
If you’re introducing someone to Steubenville-area pizza, this is usually stop number one. Order by the square, expect a light crust with a tangy sauce, and watch the cold cheese go on right before it’s boxed. It’s takeout-focused, so plan to grab a stack of boxes and head back to New Alexandria or a nearby park.
02
Old-school neighborhood favorite
Giannamore's Pizza
West Steubenville • Takeout-Only Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Crispy Squares
Giannamore’s serves ultra-crispy, square-cut pies that locals swear by for game nights and casual family gatherings.
This small, no-frills shop leans into the Ohio Valley tradition with crunchy-edged squares and a generous layer of cheese. The menu is tight, but the focus is on consistently good pizza rather than extras. Call ahead during peak times, as regulars know the best hours and the rush can be intense on Friday and Saturday evenings.
03
Cozy small-town choice
Ray's Pizza
Wintersville • Casual Sit-Down And Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Families
Ray’s offers a comfortable small-town dining room, friendly service, and hearty pizzas that work well for family dinners after a day out.
Compared with the strictly takeout spots, Ray’s is where you can actually sit down, relax, and let everyone dig into their own favorite topping combinations. The crust leans toward classic American, with plenty of cheese and a sauce that’s mild enough for picky eaters. It’s an easy, low-stress option when you’ve got a mixed crowd and want more than just a quick pickup run.
04
Classic Italian with pizza
Naples Spaghetti House
Downtown Steubenville • Old-School Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Most Versatile Menu
Naples is a longtime Steubenville institution where you can pair a solid pizza with classic pasta dishes in a nostalgic dining room.
While it’s best known for red-sauce comfort food, the pizza here holds its own, especially if you like a softer, more traditional round pie. It’s a great pick when some of your group wants lasagna or spaghetti and others are firmly in the pizza camp. The atmosphere is warm and a little retro, making it a nice choice for unhurried dinners after a drive up from New Alexandria.
05
Reliable chain option
Domino's Pizza - Steubenville
Steubenville Hilltop • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Late-Night Delivery
The Steubenville Domino’s is the practical pick when you want predictable pizza delivered out toward New Alexandria without much hassle.
It may not have the local mystique of the old-school shops, but Domino’s fills a real need for late-night or last-minute orders. The online ordering, tracking, and consistent menu make it especially handy if you’re hosting a crowd and don’t want to juggle multiple specialty spots. For busy weeknights or game days when convenience wins, this location is the one locals default to.