01
Best overall pick
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
St. Clairsville - Downtown • Ohio Valley-Style Pizzeria With Dine-In And Carryout • Top Choice For Classic Pies And Loaded Toppings
DeFelice Bros. serves the chewy-crust, edge-to-edge-topped pies that define the Ohio Valley pizza style.
If you grew up in the valley, this is probably what you think of when someone says "pizza night." The crust is sturdy but not heavy, the toppings go right to the edge, and the sauce has that slightly sweet, nostalgic flavor people swear by. It is worth the drive from New Athens when you want something that feels local and a little old-school.
02
Fastest delivery from Cadiz
Domino's Pizza
Cadiz • National Delivery Chain With Custom-Built Pies • Reliable Late-Night Delivery Option
Domino's in Cadiz is the quickest way to get a hot, customizable pizza delivered down the back roads toward New Athens.
This is the spot locals lean on when nobody feels like cooking and the game is already on. The online ordering makes it easy to tweak crusts, sauces, and toppings, and the Cadiz store is used to runs out toward the smaller villages. It is more about speed and consistency than romance, but it hits the spot when you just want hot, cheesy comfort food fast.
03
Family sit-down choice
Pizza Hut
Cadiz • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Pizza Spot • Best For Family Dinners And Big Group Orders
The Cadiz Pizza Hut is a familiar stop when you want pan pizzas, wings, and breadsticks without driving to a bigger city.
If you are wrangling kids or a ball team, this is an easy place to land. The booths, big pitchers of soda, and shareable baskets of breadsticks make it simple to feed a crowd on a budget. Call ahead for larger orders and you can bring enough pan pizza back to New Athens to cover a whole get-together.
04
Best for specialty toppings
Vocelli Pizza
St. Clairsville - Plaza Area • Delivery-Focused Pizzeria With Creative Combos • Go-To For Gourmet-Style Pies Close To I-70
Vocelli in St. Clairsville leans into specialty pies and crust options that feel like a step up from the usual chains.
When you want something a little more interesting than pepperoni and cheese, Vocelli is a smart call. Their menu runs from chicken club and steak pizzas to white pies with garlic and spinach, plus thick-cut pepperoni that crisps up nicely. It is especially handy if you are already in St. Clairsville running errands and want to bring a more "restaurant-style" pizza back home.
05
Italian restaurant with standout pizza
Undo's Italian Restaurant
St. Clairsville - Near The Mall • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Bar • Best For Lingering Dinners And Date Nights
Undo's mixes classic Italian dishes with generously topped pizzas in a comfortable, old-school dining room.
This is where you go when pizza is part of a night out, not just a takeout box. The pies come with a softer, bakery-style crust and plenty of cheese, and you can round things out with wings, salads, or a plate of pasta. It is a relaxed, slightly old-fashioned place that works just as well for a casual date as it does for a family meal after a day at the mall.