01
Best overall pick
Donatos Pizza
Marion – East Center Street Corridor • Ohio Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Crispy Thin Crust
A go-to for New Bloomington locals who like their pizzas thin, crispy, and piled with toppings.
Donatos is a classic Ohio name, and the Marion location is an easy jump from New Bloomington when you want consistently good, edge-to-edge toppings. The signature thin crust stays crisp even on the drive home, and the menu has plenty of shareable options, from pepperoni-heavy pies to simple cheese for picky eaters. It is a smart pick when you are feeding a crowd and want reliable quality without guessing.
02
Best for late nights
Domino's Pizza
Marion – North Main Street Area • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Late-Night Delivery Pick
When it is late, you are tired, and you just want hot pizza brought to your door near New Bloomington, Domino's is the standby.
This is the spot New Bloomington residents lean on when they would rather stay home and let the pizza come to them. The Marion Domino's runs an efficient delivery game, with online ordering, tracking, and plenty of mix-and-match deals. Between the customizable crusts, wings, and stuffed cheesy bread, it works well for game nights or quick weeknight dinners.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Marion – Barks Road Shopping Strip • Family-Friendly Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Families
Classic pan pizzas and roomy booths make the Marion Pizza Hut an easy family outing from New Bloomington.
If you grew up on pan pizza, breadsticks, and red-check tabletops, this spot scratches that nostalgic itch. The dine-in setup gives families a chance to sit down, relax, and let the kids split a pizza while you catch up over a pitcher of soda. It is also convenient to swing by for carryout on the way back toward New Bloomington after errands in Marion.
04
Best quick stop
Little Caesars
Marion – South Prospect Street • Grab-And-Go Budget Pizza Spot • Best For A Quick Bite
For fast, no-fuss pizza at a budget-friendly price, Little Caesars in Marion is hard to beat.
This is the place you hit when you want to grab a pizza on the way back through Marion without waiting around. The Hot-N-Ready options mean you can be back in the car in minutes, and the prices make it easy to feed a hungry carload of kids or friends. It is not fancy, but it is reliably hot, filling, and easy on the wallet.
05
Best for custom orders
Papa John's Pizza
Marion – Downtown • Toppings-Heavy Chain Pizzeria • Game-Night Crowd Pleaser
Papa John's in Marion is a solid choice when you want lots of topping options and an extra tub of garlic sauce for dipping.
With its focus on build-your-own pies and specialty combinations, this spot works well for mixed groups where everyone has a strong opinion on toppings. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of extras, and the garlic butter and pepper on the side are small touches people look forward to. Order ahead for pickup on your way back to New Bloomington and you will have dinner sorted before you even get home.