01
Best for convenient delivery
Papa Johns Pizza
New Boston • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Go-To Neighborhood Option
New Boston’s own Papa Johns is the easiest way to grab a hot, made-to-order pizza without leaving the village.
Set right along Gallia Street, this location is the definition of convenient if you live in or near New Boston. The menu leans on familiar favorites—think customizable pies, garlic knots, and wings—so it’s easy to keep a group happy. It’s especially handy for game nights or last-minute dinners when you want something predictable, quick, and close to home.
02
Best for family buffet
Giovanni’s Pizza
East Portsmouth • Family-Style Pizzeria And Buffet • Best For Families And Groups
Giovanni’s pairs classic sheet-pan style pies with a well-loved buffet that’s ideal for big appetites.
A short drive from New Boston, Giovanni’s on 11th Street is where many locals head when they want pizza plus plenty of extras. The crust is on the heartier side, with generous toppings and that nostalgic, slightly sweet sauce many Ohio valley pizza fans swear by. Add in pasta, salad, and a casual dining room, and it’s a strong pick for team dinners, birthday gatherings, or feeding a crowd on a budget.
03
Best for craft pies
Oddfellows
Downtown Portsmouth • Craft Pizza And Entertainment Spot • Best For A Night Out
Oddfellows brings creative, bar-style pizzas and a lively atmosphere to downtown Portsmouth.
If you’re willing to make the quick drive into downtown, Oddfellows is the most ‘big-city’ pizza experience in easy reach of New Boston. The pies lean modern and fun, with toppings that go beyond the standard pepperoni-and-cheese lineup, plus a good selection of drinks. It’s a natural choice when you want pizza to be part of an evening out, not just something in a cardboard box.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino’s Pizza
Downtown-Adjacent Portsmouth • National Delivery Pizzeria • Reliable Late Option
Domino’s in Portsmouth covers New Boston with fast delivery, custom crusts, and consistent, late-hours service.
For those nights when you’re keeping an eye on the clock and the score, Domino’s is the workhorse of the local pizza scene. The menu is built around mix-and-match value deals, multiple crust options, and plenty of add-ons like stuffed cheesy bread and wings. It’s not trying to be fancy, but for straightforward, trackable delivery to New Boston, it does exactly what you need it to do.
05
Best for dine-in nostalgia
Pizza Hut
Scioto Trail Corridor • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Classic Sit-Down Choice
This Pizza Hut on Scioto Trail offers pan pizzas, breadsticks, and a familiar sit-down experience within easy reach of New Boston.
If you grew up on red cups and pan pizza, this spot taps straight into that nostalgia. The menu focuses on thick, buttery-crust pies, stuffed crusts, and shareable sides that work well for families or small groups meeting in the middle between Portsmouth and New Boston. It’s an easy, low-stress option when you want to sit down, refill your drinks, and let someone else handle the dishes.