01
Best overall pick
Bud's Pizza
Minster • Small-Town Pizza Institution • Destination-Worthy Classic
A short hop from New Bremen, Bud’s serves the kind of crispy, loaded pies locals grow up on and keep coming back for.
If you ask around New Bremen where to drive for a ‘real’ pizza night, Bud’s in Minster comes up fast. Expect a classic Ohio-style crust, generous toppings, and that slightly sweet, nostalgia-leaning sauce that keeps it firmly in the comfort-food category. It’s a relaxed, family-friendly stop that feels built for post-game celebrations and Friday traditions.
02
Most convenient in-town
Pizza Hut
State Route 66 Corridor • National Chain Carryout And Dine-In • Reliable Weeknight Staple
New Bremen’s Pizza Hut is the go-to for predictable pies, quick carryout, and team orders after a busy evening.
For many residents, this is the easiest choice when a pizza craving hits and nobody wants to cook. The menu is familiar, from pan pizzas and stuffed crust to wings and breadsticks, and online ordering keeps pickup smooth on hectic nights. It’s especially handy for feeding a crowd after practices or when family is in from out of town and wants something simple.
03
Best for families and leagues
Speedway Lanes
Near The Heart Of New Bremen • Bowling Alley Pizza & Grill • Fun Night-Out Choice
Speedway Lanes pairs better-than-you’d-expect pizza with bowling, making it a natural pick for families and small groups.
This isn’t just a place to roll a few frames—locals know the kitchen turns out solid pies that hit the spot while you’re keeping score. The vibe is casual and social, with pizza, burgers, and snacks fueling league nights and birthday parties alike. It’s ideal when you want your pizza with a little built-in entertainment instead of a quick in-and-out pickup run.
04
Best for big groups and games
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
St. Marys • Lively Sports Bar & Pizza Grill • Game-Day Hangout
Beer Barrel in St. Marys offers shareable pizzas, a full menu, and plenty of TVs for a louder, sports-bar-style night out.
If you’re organizing a friends’ night or need room for a larger group, this is the spot that can handle it without blinking. The pizza menu leans into hearty, crowd-pleasing combos, and there’s enough variety in appetizers, salads, and mains to keep non-pizza folks happy. Expect a busier, upbeat atmosphere, especially on big game days and weekend evenings.
05
Coziest nearby option
Guarnieri Pizzeria
St. Marys • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Laid-Back Sit-Down Spot
Guarnieri Pizzeria offers a more traditional, sit-down pizza experience that feels like a comfortable extension of the neighborhood.
Tucked over in St. Marys, this is a nice choice when you’re in the mood to linger over a pie instead of rushing home with a box. The pizzas tend to lean classic rather than experimental, with straightforward toppings and a focus on doing the basics right. It’s a low-key, friendly stop that works just as well for a casual date as it does for a quiet family dinner.