01
Best overall pick
LaRosa’s Pizzeria – Mt. Healthy
Mt. Healthy • Classic Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Local Standby For All-Ages Gatherings
A go-to for New Burlington families, with familiar LaRosa’s pies, pasta, and hoagies just minutes down Hamilton Avenue.
This Mt. Healthy outpost delivers the full LaRosa’s experience without the drive toward downtown. The crust is soft and sauce-forward, with plenty of customizable toppings and crowd-pleasing specialty pies. It’s an easy pick when you need consistent pizza, kid-friendly booths, and dependable takeout any night of the week.
02
Old-school favorite
Chester’s Pizza
White Oak • Neighborhood Carryout Pizza Joint • Best For Crispy Edge-To-Edge Pies
A long-running west-side favorite known for thin, crispy pizzas loaded right to the edge with toppings.
Chester’s is the kind of no-frills shop locals grow up with and keep coming back to. The pizzas lean thin and crisp, with a generous layer of cheese and toppings that run nearly to the crust. Call ahead, pick up, and you’re back in New Burlington with hot, old-school Cincinnati comfort food in under 15 minutes.
03
Best for a quick local slice
Angilo’s Pizza – North College Hill
North College Hill • Casual Carryout And Delivery Spot • Weeknight Takeout Workhorse
A close-by classic for New Burlington residents who want straightforward, affordable pies and hoagies without overthinking the order.
Angilo’s in North College Hill keeps it simple: solid pies, loaded hoagies, and quick service from just down the road. The crust sits in the middle ground between thin and doughy, making it easy to please a mixed group. It’s especially handy on busy nights when you want something familiar, hot, and on the table fast.
04
Biggest flavor per slice
Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza
Clifton / Uc Area • Hearty College-Town Pizzeria • Best For Thick, Shareable Pies
A UC-campus staple, famous for hefty, square-cut pizzas that are worth the short drive from New Burlington when you’re feeding a crowd.
Adriatico’s has a loyal following for its heavy, saucy pies with chewy crust and serious cheese pull. The square party pizzas travel well, making them ideal for game nights or big family gatherings back in New Burlington. Expect a louder, college-energy shop, but the flavor and portion sizes more than justify the trip.
05
Best late-night option
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Over-the-Rhine
Over-The-Rhine • New York–Style Slice Shop • Late-Night And Downtown Outing Pick
Oversized New York–style slices and whole pies make this OTR stop a smart move when your pizza craving hits after an evening downtown.
Goodfellas serves up big, foldable slices with a thin yet sturdy crust and plenty of classic topping combinations. It’s an easy add-on to a night out in Over-the-Rhine, especially if you want something casual and filling before heading back north. Grab a slice at the counter or share a whole pie if you’ve brought friends from New Burlington along for the evening.