01
Best overall pick
Jan & Tony's Pizza
Plain City • Small-Town Family Pizzeria • Go-To Local Classic
A Plain City staple turning out crowd-pleasing pies, subs, and salads that feel just right for a regular weeknight dinner.
Jan & Tony's is the kind of place where the staff learns your regular order and the pizza leans classic: plenty of cheese, a straightforward sauce, and toppings stacked edge to edge. The menu is broad enough to keep a family happy, with subs, wings, and pasta rounding things out. It’s an easy, no-fuss choice when you want reliable carryout close to New California.
02
For craft toppings and cocktails
Harvest Pizzeria Dublin
Bridge Park In Dublin • Modern Craft Pizza And Bar • Best For Date Night
Wood-fired pies with creative toppings, a strong bar program, and a polished-but-relaxed feel right in Bridge Park.
Harvest Pizzeria in Dublin is the move when you want something a step up from standard takeout. Expect blistered crusts, seasonal toppings, and thoughtful combinations that range from classic pepperoni to pies with spicy sausage, local veggies, or hot honey. With good cocktails, local beer, and a buzzy dining room, it works equally well for date night or catching up with friends over a shared pizza or two.
03
Classic Columbus-style pick
Tommy's Pizza Dublin
Frantz Road Corridor In Dublin • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Shop • Game-Day Favorite
Old-school, square-cut Columbus-style pizza with a loyal following and a casual, no-frills atmosphere.
Tommy's has been synonymous with Columbus-style pizza for decades, and the Dublin outpost brings that same super-thin, crisp crust and edge-to-edge toppings within easy reach of New California. Pies come cut into small squares, perfect for sharing with a group or snacking through a game. Add in wings, subs, and cold beer and you’ve got an easygoing spot to post up on a Friday night or grab a big carryout order for a watch party.
04
Best for a night out
Benny's Pizza
Marysville • Lively Pizza Pub With Patio • Best For Live Music And Groups
Generous, shareable pies served alongside live music and a big patio that makes it feel like an event, not just dinner.
Benny's is a Marysville institution, known as much for its backyard-style patio and frequent live music as for its pizzas. The crust is sturdy enough to hold lots of toppings, and you’ll see plenty of big groups splitting a few specialty pies and baskets of wings. On warm evenings, the outdoor space is one of the more lively spots within a short drive of New California, especially if you’re meeting friends or celebrating a birthday.
05
Best family outing
Plain City Lanes & Pizza
West Side Of Plain City • Bowling Alley With Classic Pizza Counter • Family-Friendly Hangout
Casual, kid-friendly pizza and bowling under one roof, ideal when you want a built-in activity with your meal.
Plain City Lanes & Pizza is a reliable pick when you’ve got kids to entertain or a mixed-age group to feed. The pizza is straightforward and satisfying—think classic pepperoni, sausage, and deluxe pies that come out hot between bowling frames. It’s especially handy for birthday parties, rainy-day outings, or any time you want an easy, all-in-one plan close to New California.