01
Best overall pick
571 Grill & Draft House
Along Oh-571 East Of Town • Lively Grill With Craft Beer And Handmade Pizzas • Local Favorite For A Full Meal And A Pie
A busy local hangout where you can pair creative pizzas with one of the strongest tap lists around New Carlisle.
The pizzas here feel more like a centerpiece than an afterthought, with chewy crusts, quality toppings, and plenty of build-your-own options. It’s the kind of place where you linger over a pie, fries, and a pint rather than rushing in and out. Go on the early side on weekends if you want a quieter table; the dining room fills up fast with regulars.
02
Coziest family spot
Carmela's Pizzeria
South Dayton–Lakeview Road Corridor • Family-Owned Ny-Style Pizzeria • Best For Families And Big Appetites
Generous NY-style pies, subs, and pastas make this an easy choice when you’re feeding a crowd on the east side of town.
Carmela’s leans into classic comfort food: foldable slices, loaded specialty pizzas, and plenty of red-sauce standbys. The dining room is relaxed and kid-friendly, with service that feels more like a neighborhood spot than a chain. It’s a smart pick for casual dinners, team celebrations, or an affordable pizza-and-pasta night out.
03
Quick delivery favorite
Domino's Pizza
South Main Street • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Fast Delivery Standby
When you want consistent, customized pizza delivered around New Carlisle, this South Main Street Domino’s is hard to beat for sheer convenience.
With online ordering and a well-practiced delivery crew, Domino’s is the go-to option for busy weeknights and last-minute gatherings. The menu stretches beyond basic pies to include stuffed cheesy bread, wings, and desserts, so everyone can tack on their favorites. It’s a reliable choice when speed and predictability matter more than lingering over a sit-down meal.
04
Best chain for game night
Papa Johns Pizza
North Main Street • Takeout-Focused Pizza Chain • Game-Night Go-To
Thicker crust pies, dipping sauces, and bundle deals make this North Main spot a natural fit for pizza-and-wings evenings.
Papa Johns leans into hearty, topping-heavy pizzas, with that signature garlic dipping sauce and pepperoncini in every box. It’s especially handy when you’re ordering for a group watching the game, thanks to combo deals and plenty of shareable sides. Call ahead or order online and swing by the storefront to grab your food hot and ready.
05
Old-school neighborhood favorite
Ronetti's Pizza
Short Drive South To Medway • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Classic
A no-frills Clark County staple where locals swear by the crispy, edge-to-edge toppings and hometown vibe.
Just a short drive from New Carlisle, Ronetti’s feels like stepping into a time capsule of small-town Ohio pizza. Expect classic, square-cut pies with plenty of cheese and a crust that holds up well on the ride home. It’s especially popular for carryout on weekends, so calling in your order ahead of time is a smart move.