01
Best overall pick
J. Marie’s Wood-Fired Kitchen & Drinks
Downtown Wapakoneta • Cozy Wood-Fired Bistro • Destination For Sit-Down Pizza
A polished downtown spot where the wood-fired oven turns out the area’s most memorable pies.
If you’re starting your pizza search closest to New Hampshire, J. Marie’s in Wapakoneta is the place locals name first. The crust comes out blistered and chewy from the wood-fired oven, with toppings that lean more creative than your standard corner shop. It’s an easy choice when you want a proper night out with good pizza, a glass of wine or craft beer, and a stroll around the historic downtown afterward.
02
Best for groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Near Grand Lake St. Marys • Lively Family Pizza & Grill • Great For Big Parties And Teams
Big, shareable pizzas and a roomy dining room make this St. Marys mainstay ideal for families and teams after the game.
Beer Barrel in St. Marys is built for gatherings, with long tables, big screens, and pizzas that can easily feed a crowd. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, so everyone at the table can find something without overthinking it. It’s the kind of place where birthday dinners, team celebrations, and lake-weekend meetups all feel right at home.
03
Classic carryout favorite
Fat Jack’s Pizza
East Lima • Old-School Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Takeout Night
A long-running Lima staple known for its generous toppings, crispy edges, and reliable delivery radius.
When folks in the Lima area talk about a go-to Friday night pizza, Fat Jack’s comes up fast. The pies lean hearty, with plenty of cheese, edge-to-edge toppings, and that slightly crisp crust you only get from a seasoned deck oven. It’s a bit of a drive from New Hampshire, but if you’re already in Lima for errands, grabbing a box from here to bring back home is a smart move.
04
Best old-school vibe
Guarnieri’s Pizzeria
North Lima Neighborhood • Classic Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Local Favorite
A no-frills neighborhood pizzeria turning out thin, saucy pies that taste like small-town Ohio in the best way.
Guarnieri’s feels like the kind of pizza shop every Midwestern town used to have: unpretentious, affordable, and focused on getting the basics right. The crust is on the thinner side, the sauce has a little sweetness, and the toppings are the familiar lineup locals grew up with. If you like your pizza straightforward and nostalgic rather than fussy, this is worth the extra few minutes beyond the chain options along the main roads.
05
Best for craft-style pies
Heirloom Pizza Company
Downtown Lima • Modern Craft Pizzeria • Good For Food-Focused Outings
A newer-school spot where thoughtfully sourced ingredients and inventive topping combos meet a well-made crust.
Heirloom Pizza Company brings a more modern, ingredient-first approach to the Lima-area pizza scene. Expect creative combinations, seasonal specials, and a crust that tastes like someone has put serious time into getting the dough right. It’s a strong choice when you’re making a night of it in downtown Lima and want pizza that feels a bit more of-the-moment without being overly precious.