01
Best overall pick
Pizza Cottage
Circleville – North Side • Lively Dine-In Pizzeria With A Big Menu • Great For Families And Groups
Big portions, plenty of topping combos, and friendly service make Pizza Cottage a dependable stop after the drive from New Holland.
Pizza Cottage is the place you go when everyone in the car wants something a little different but you only want to make one stop. Hand-tossed pies, thick-cut pepperoni, and a solid lineup of specialty pizzas are backed up by hearty appetizers and salads that can easily feed a crew. It sits right along the main route into Circleville, so it is an easy choice when you're already in town for errands or a game.
02
Classic small-town tavern feel
Gant's Pizza & Pub
Circleville – Downtown • Pub-Style Pizzeria And Bar • Best For A Relaxed Night With A Beer
A cozy downtown spot where square-cut pizza, cold drinks, and locals at the bar set the tone.
Gant's leans into that old-school Ohio tavern vibe: simple, well-made pizzas, a good beer selection, and TVs tuned to whatever game matters that night. The crust is on the thinner side and cut into shareable squares, perfect for grazing with friends. Grab a table, order a pie and some wings, and settle in for an unhurried evening just off Circleville's main drag.
03
Reliable chain favorite
Donatos Pizza
Circleville – East Side • Ohio Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Easy Carry-Out Or Delivery
Edge-to-edge toppings and quick service make this Donatos a go-to when you want pizza on the table without fuss.
If you like your pizza thin, crispy, and loaded all the way to the crust, the Circleville Donatos does it exactly the way you'd expect. Online ordering is straightforward, the staff keeps orders moving, and the menu has enough subs, salads, and wings to round out a full family meal. It is a convenient option when you're heading back toward New Holland and want to grab dinner on the way out of town.
04
Old-school Italian-American
Giovanni's Pizza
Washington Court House – In Town • Sit-Down Pizza And Pasta Spot • Good For Lingering Meals
Hearty pizzas, baked pasta, and subs give Giovanni's the feel of a small-town Italian family joint.
Giovanni's in Washington Court House is the kind of place where a simple pepperoni pizza comes buried under cheese, and no one rushes you out after you finish eating. Beyond the pies, there are saucy pasta dishes, toasted subs, and plenty of sides if you want more than just a slice. It is a bit of a drive west from New Holland, but it pays off when you want a sit-down dinner instead of a quick box to go.
05
Weeknight standby
Donatos Pizza
Washington Court House – Commercial Strip • Fast, Consistent Pizza Chain • Quick Stop On The Way Home
A straightforward, no-surprises Donatos that shines when you need reliable pizza after a long day.
This Washington Court House Donatos is all about convenience: easy parking, quick turnaround times, and the same familiar edge-to-edge pies you get across Ohio. It works especially well for team dinners after games in town or last-minute carry-out when you don't feel like cooking back in New Holland. Order ahead, swing through, and you'll be back on the road with hot pizza in minutes.