01
Classic small-town favorite
Bud's Pizza
Minster • Old-School Tavern Pizza • Local Institution
A longtime Minster standby turning out crispy, square-cut pies in a no-frills, hometown setting.
Bud's feels exactly like the kind of place you hope to find in a west-central Ohio village: straightforward, friendly, and serious about its pizza. Expect thin, crackly crust, generous toppings, and that classic square-cut style locals grew up on. It’s an easy go-to when you want an unfussy, reliably good pie a few minutes from New Knoxville.
02
Best all-rounder nearby
Padrone's Pizza
New Bremen • Casual Hometown Pizzeria • Crowd-Pleasing Pick
A New Bremen staple with a broad menu, from loaded specialty pies to classic pepperoni that travels well back to New Knoxville.
This Padrone's location is popular with teams, families, and anyone feeding a group thanks to its reliably consistent pies and plenty of topping combos. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with a sturdy base that holds up to extra cheese and meat-heavy orders. It’s a smart choice when you’re calling in a pizza run before a game or a low-key night at home.
03
Cozy pub with character
Guarnieri's Pizzeria & Pub
St. Marys • Neighborhood Pizzeria & Pub • Best For Lingering Over A Pie
A warm, wood-paneled pub vibe paired with hearty pizzas that feel made for lingering over a second drink.
Guarnieri's leans into the comfortable side of pizza night, with a sit-down pub atmosphere and pies that match the mood. Crusts are on the heartier side, built to hold plenty of toppings, from classic sausage and mushroom to more loaded combinations. It’s a good call when you want to make an evening of it rather than just grabbing a box to go.
04
Best for wood-fired pizza
J. Marie's Wood-Fired Kitchen & Drinks
Downtown Wapakoneta • Wood-Fired Kitchen & Bar • Elevated Night Out
Downtown Wapakoneta’s stylish spot for blistered, wood-fired pizzas and a fuller dinner-and-drinks experience.
J. Marie's brings a more polished feel to the local pizza scene, with a big oven turning out charred, chewy crusts and thoughtfully topped pies. The menu goes beyond pizza, but the pies are the star, especially if you like a little smoke on the crust and fresh, colorful toppings. Pair it with a drink and you’ve got an easy date-night destination that still keeps New Knoxville within a short drive home.
05
Best for big groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
St. Marys • Lively Pizza & Grill • Great For Families And Teams
A roomy, energetic spot with oversized, shareable pizzas and a full menu to keep everyone at the table happy.
Beer Barrel is built for gatherings, with plenty of seating and pizzas that land in the middle of the table and disappear fast. The crust is thicker and more substantial, with lots of cheese and classic topping combinations that hit familiar comfort-food notes. It’s especially handy after tournaments or lake days when you’ve got a mix of ages and appetites to feed.