01
Classic hometown pick
Cassano's Pizza King
West Main Street, New Lebanon • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Everyday Pizza Night
Crisp, square-cut pies and familiar flavors make Cassano’s the default choice for many New Lebanon families.
If you grew up anywhere around Dayton, Cassano’s is probably the pizza you remember from school parties and Friday nights. The New Lebanon shop keeps that tradition going with cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and an easygoing counter-service vibe. It is the spot locals rely on for quick carryout after a ballgame or a low-fuss family dinner.
02
Best delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Brookville, North Of New Lebanon • Fast-Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night And Game-Day Delivery
Domino’s in nearby Brookville is the go-to when you want hot pizza dropped at your door with minimal planning.
For New Lebanon residents on the north side of town, the Brookville Domino’s is close enough to make delivery a realistic weeknight option. The menu covers all the bases—custom-build pies, specialty pizzas, wings, and cheesy breads—so everyone at the table can find something. It is a reliable pick when you care more about speed and consistency than lingering over a sit-down meal.
03
Dayton institution worth the drive
Marion's Piazza
Englewood, Northwest Dayton • Old-School Square-Cut Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Team Parties
Marion’s serves ultra-thin, generously topped pizzas in a sprawling dining room that feels built for teams, families, and birthday parties.
Ask around and you will hear Marion’s mentioned as one of the defining Dayton pizza experiences, and the Englewood location is the easiest one to reach from New Lebanon. Expect super-thin crust, finely crumbled toppings, and pizzas cut into small squares that are made for sharing. The cavernous dining room, plenty of seating, and quick service make it a natural choice for youth teams, church groups, and multi-family outings.
04
Best artisan pies
Old Scratch Pizza
Near Downtown Dayton • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria • Best For Craft Beer And Creative Toppings
Old Scratch turns out blistered, chewy-crusted pies from a big open-hearth oven alongside a strong craft beer list.
When you are in the mood for something beyond classic chain pizza, Old Scratch is the move. Pies come out fast from the wood-fired oven with leopard-spotted crusts, thoughtful topping combos, and plenty of options for vegetarians. Communal tables, a rotating tap list, and counter service give it a relaxed, social feel that works as well for date night as it does for a casual group meetup.
05
Destination family night spot
Dewey's Pizza
Austin Landing, Miamisburg • Sit-Down Gourmet Pizzeria • Best For Families And Picky Eaters
Dewey’s offers polished service, creative specialty pies, and kid-friendly classics in a lively, open-kitchen setting.
Austin Landing is a bit of a drive from New Lebanon, but Dewey’s makes it feel like a proper night out. You can watch the dough-tossing show while you wait, then dive into inventive pizzas, seasonal salads, and build-your-own combinations for less adventurous diners. With attentive service and an upbeat dining room, it is a great pick when you want pizza to feel like more than just takeout.