01
Best overall pick
The Pizza Place
Downtown New Lexington • Family-Run Pizza And Pasta Restaurant • Local Favorite For Sit-Down Meals
Old-school pies, friendly service, and a small-town dining room make The Pizza Place the heart of New Lexington’s pizza scene.
Expect classic, hand-tossed pizzas with chewy crusts, plenty of cheese, and toppings that feel a step up from the chains. The menu stretches beyond pies with pasta, salads, and appetizers, so everyone at the table can find something. It’s the kind of place where staff remember regulars and families linger over an extra basket of garlic bread.
02
Go-to delivery option
Domino's Pizza
North Main Street Corridor • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery Cravings
Fast delivery, consistent pies, and lots of custom options keep this Domino’s in regular rotation for locals.
If you want pizza on the couch without leaving the house, this is the reliable move in New Lexington. Build your own pie with every topping combination imaginable, or lean on favorites like hand-tossed pepperoni, specialty chicken, and oven-baked sandwiches. Online ordering and the tracking app make it easy to time dinner with the game or movie night.
03
Family-friendly chain
Pizza Hut
Carroll Street Commercial Strip • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Pizzeria • Best For Kids And Big Groups
Pan pizzas, shareable sides, and roomy seating make this Pizza Hut a straightforward choice for families.
This spot is built for crowd-pleasing orders: think thick pan pizzas, stuffed crust splurges, and big trays of breadsticks or wings in the middle of the table. It’s an easy stop after games or school events, with quick service and plenty of familiar flavors for picky eaters. Carryout is just as popular, especially when you want a bundle of pizzas and pastas without cooking for a crowd.
04
Small-town classic
Cristy's Pizza
Historic Somerset Village, North Of New Lexington • Carryout-Focused Local Ohio Pizza Chain • Best For Customizable Takeout
Thin, slightly crispy crust and generous toppings have made Cristy’s a go-to takeout stop in nearby Somerset.
Cristy’s leans into that classic Ohio-style pie: plenty of toppings spread edge to edge on a thinner crust, cut into easy-to-share squares. Locals like the build-your-own options as much as the specialty pizzas, and the menu rounds out with subs, salads, and cheesy bread. It’s an easy detour for takeout when you’re heading toward Somerset or passing through on the way to Lancaster.
05
Worth-the-drive destination
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan, East Of Hocking Hills • Bustling Hometown Pizzeria And Bar • Best For Hearty, Loaded Pies
Piled-high toppings, chewy crust, and a lively small-town vibe make Pizza Crossing a destination pie within easy driving distance.
People make the trip to Logan specifically for these generously loaded pizzas, where every slice feels like a full meal. The dining room has the energy of a classic hometown hangout, with big pitchers of soda, baskets of garlic bread, and plenty of chatter around the TVs. It’s a smart choice before or after a Hocking Hills hike, especially if you’re craving something substantial and shareable.