01
Best overall pick
New London Pizza House
Downtown New London • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A village staple serving generously topped pies and familiar, no-fuss comfort food.
Right in the heart of town, New London Pizza House is the kind of spot locals grow up on and keep coming back to. The menu leans into classic hand-tossed pizzas with plenty of topping combinations, plus subs and wings for mixed groups. It’s an easy go-to when you want something everyone at the table will recognize and enjoy.
02
Old-school slice stop
Mr Pizza Head
South Main Street, New London • Casual Main Street Shop • Best For Quick Carryout
Compact, unfussy, and all about hot, cheesy pizzas ready for pick-up.
Mr Pizza Head feels like a throwback in the best way, with straightforward pies and a focus on getting your order out hot and fast. It’s a natural fit for weeknights when you’re cruising down Main and want something easy to bring home. Call ahead, swing by, and you’re back on the road with dinner in the passenger seat.
03
Most customizable pies
Domino's Pizza
Norwalk East Side • National Delivery Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Endless topping combos, app-based ordering, and dependable delivery from nearby Norwalk.
If you’re in New London and want a fully build-your-own pizza without leaving the couch, Domino’s in Norwalk is often the easiest play. Their online and app ordering make it simple to tweak crust, sauce, and toppings for picky eaters or adventurous combos. It’s especially handy on late nights when local kitchens have already closed.
04
Fast and budget-friendly
Little Caesars Pizza
Norwalk Retail Strip • Carryout Chain Spot • Best Value Pick
Grab-and-go pies that are easy on the wallet and ideal for feeding a crowd in a hurry.
For quick stops between errands or on the way back to New London, Little Caesars in Norwalk is built around speed and price. The Hot-N-Ready model means you can usually walk in, grab a couple of pepperoni or cheese pizzas, and be back in the car in minutes. It’s a smart move for kids’ sleepovers, team snacks, or any time quantity matters as much as variety.
05
Loaded specialty pizzas
Marco's Pizza
South Norwalk • Modern Delivery And Carryout • Best For Big Groups
Hearty, topping-heavy pizzas and subs that travel well back to New London.
Marco’s in Norwalk leans into bold flavors, from meaty specialty pies to garlicky cheese breads and oven-baked subs. Portions are generous, making it a reliable option when you’re feeding a mix of teens, friends, or extended family. Order a couple of large specialty pizzas and some sides, and you’ve got an easy spread for game night back in New London.