01
Best overall pick
Red Front Pizza & Grill
In The Heart Of New Paris • Small-Town Bar And Grill Pizzeria • Go-To Local Gathering Spot
The New Paris original for hearty, Midwest-style pizzas in a laid-back bar-and-grill setting.
Red Front is the kind of place where New Paris neighbors bump into each other over a Friday night pizza and a draft beer. Pies lean classic and generously topped, from straightforward pepperoni to fun specialties like taco-inspired creations. It is relaxed, friendly, and exactly what you want when you do not feel like driving far but still want a proper sit-down pizza night.
02
Classic regional chain
Pizza King (Richmond)
Richmond, Indiana • Retro Regional Pizza Joint • Nostalgic Pick For Crisp-Edge Pies
An Indiana-born chain loved for its thin, crispy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and old-school feel.
Many New Paris locals cross into Richmond when they are craving Pizza King’s signature thin crust and toppings that reach right to the edge. Expect a no-frills dining room, familiar red-and-white decor, and quick service that suits families as well as small groups of friends. It is a reliable option when you want that distinct regional style you grew up on, rather than something fancy.
03
Best downtown outing
Little Sheba's
Downtown Richmond • Eclectic Pub-Style Restaurant With Pizza • Great For Groups And Casual Nights Out
A lively downtown Richmond spot where hand-tossed pizzas share the menu with sandwiches, salads, and a solid beer list.
Little Sheba's is a smart choice when your group cannot agree on just pizza but still wants a good pie on the table. The crust has a satisfying chew, toppings are creative without getting gimmicky, and the atmosphere feels more like a neighborhood pub than a typical pizzeria. It is especially appealing if you want to make a night of it downtown, with time to wander Richmond’s historic streets before or after you eat.
04
Best lakeside vibe
Red Front Pizza & Grill (Lake Lakengren)
Near Lake Lakengren, Eaton • Lakeside Grill And Pizzeria • Relaxed Weekend Escape
A second Red Front location that brings the same hearty pizzas to a leisurely lakeside setting south of New Paris.
If you find yourself near Lake Lakengren or heading toward Eaton, this Red Front outpost is a relaxed place to unwind over a pizza after time on the water or the back roads. The menu mirrors the New Paris favorite, with familiar specialty pies and plenty of appetizers to share. It is an easy choice when you want something that feels low-key and neighborly but just far enough from home to feel like a mini getaway.
05
Most convenient chain option
Papa Johns Pizza
Eaton, Ohio • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Fast, Predictable Crowd-Pleaser
A nearby Eaton location that delivers the brand’s familiar crust, sauces, and toppings for easy takeout or delivery nights.
When convenience matters more than ambiance, the Eaton Papa Johns is often the simplest call from New Paris and the surrounding countryside. You know exactly what you are getting, from the garlic butter cups to the build-your-own combinations and specialty pies. It is especially handy for busy weeknight dinners, kids’ sleepovers, or any time you want pizza to show up without much planning.