01
Best overall pick
Penso's Pizza
East High Avenue Corridor • Old-School Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running takeout favorite known for generous toppings and classic, no-frills pies.
Penso's is the spot locals point to when you ask where they actually order their own pizza. The crust is sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and the pepperoni and sausage combos are especially popular. It’s very much a carryout-first operation, so plan on grabbing a box and heading home, to the park, or back to your hotel.
02
Classic neighborhood slice
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop
South Side, Near Downtown • Family-Run Pizza Shop • Best For Classic Recipes
A cozy, old-fashioned shop turning out nostalgic pies that taste like small-town Ohio in a box.
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop leans into the comfort side of pizza, with straightforward toppings and a sauce that regulars swear hasn’t changed in decades. Expect a friendly, everyone-knows-everyone vibe rather than trendy decor. It’s a great choice when you want familiar flavors done well, especially for a low-key family dinner or game-night takeout.
03
Under-the-radar standout
Granato's Pizza
West High Avenue Strip • Carryout-Focused Pie Joint • Best For Crispy Crust Lovers
A smaller operation that wins people over with its crisp crust and well-balanced sauce.
Granato's doesn’t chase big crowds, but it quietly pulls in regulars who care about the details of a good pie. The crust has a noticeable crunch without feeling dry, and the sauce leans savory rather than sweet, which balances nicely with classic toppings. Order ahead at peak times; the kitchen is tight, and locals know this is one of the better options on the west side of town.
04
Best sit-down choice
Maggoo's Pizza, Pasta and More
North Side, Off Wooster Avenue • Casual Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
A comfortable, family-friendly spot where you can pair a solid pizza with salads, pasta, and a lingering meal.
Maggoo's is where you go when you want pizza but also need room for a full dinner with the family or a small group. Their pies have a soft, slightly thicker crust and work well alongside the house salads and pasta dishes. It’s an easy choice for birthday dinners, team outings, or nights when you’re not in a rush and want more than a quick pickup order.
05
Best for big orders
Your Pizza Shop
Downtown Side Streets • Laid-Back Delivery And Takeout Spot • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A reliable go-to for customizable pies, big orders, and straightforward delivery or pickup.
Your Pizza Shop is built for those nights when the whole group suddenly decides on pizza and you need plenty of it fast. The menu is broad, with multiple crust options, lots of toppings, and easy-to-like specialty pies that make ordering for picky eaters simpler. It’s not fancy, but it’s consistent, affordable, and well-suited to parties, team meals, and casual hangouts.