01
Best overall pick
Coccia House Pizza
West Side Of Wooster • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Local Institution
A Wooster landmark turning out cheese-heavy, square-cut pies that locals have sworn by for generations.
If you ask almost anyone in the area where to go for pizza, Coccia House is the name you are most likely to hear. The crust is sturdy yet tender, loaded with a generous layer of cheese and toppings that lean classic rather than trendy. Expect a no-frills dining room, plenty of local chatter, and the feeling that you have stepped into a piece of Wayne County history.
02
Best for date night
Broken Rocks Cafe & Bakery
Downtown Wooster • Brick-Oven Bistro With Artisan Pizzas • Upscale Yet Relaxed Choice
Handcrafted pizzas share the menu with bistro fare, making this a go-to spot when you want something a little more polished than a basic pie.
Set right in downtown Wooster, Broken Rocks feels tailor-made for a relaxed night out, with stone-baked pizzas that pair well with a glass of wine or a local beer. The crust leans thin and chewy, topped with combinations that go beyond pepperoni into roasted veggies, fresh herbs, and quality cheeses. It is an easy pick when one person wants pizza and others are eyeing pastas, salads, or daily specials.
03
Best carryout classic
Bosco's Pizza Kitchen
East Wooster Pickup Strip • Casual Takeout And Delivery Shop • Go-To For Quick, Satisfying Pies
A straightforward, locally minded pizza kitchen that focuses on well-made, familiar pies ready for pickup or delivery.
Bosco's is the sort of spot you call when you are driving home through Wooster and suddenly realize everyone is hungry. The menu sticks to the greatest hits, with customizable pizzas, subs, and sides that hit the table hot and fast. It is not trying to be fancy, but the consistent bakes and friendly service make it a reliable choice for an easy dinner near New Pittsburg.
04
Best pizza and chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria
North Wooster Corridor • Neighborhood Pizzeria With Fried Chicken • Best For Families
Known as much for its crispy fried chicken as its loaded pies, this regional chain is a crowd-pleaser for mixed cravings.
Gionino's gives you that classic Friday-night feel, with big, cheesy pizzas and their signature JoJo-style fried chicken sharing the box. The crust is on the heartier side, built to support generous toppings and plenty of sauce. Families appreciate the combo deals and the way one order can satisfy both pizza purists and those craving something crunchy on the side.
05
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
South Wooster Near The Fairgrounds • Family Buffet And Carryout Chain • Best For Customizable Orders
A flexible choice with pan, thin, and stuffed-crust options that make it easy to feed a crowd without breaking the bank.
East of Chicago leans into variety, offering everything from thick, golden-edged pan pizza to lighter thin crusts and indulgent stuffed pies. The topping combinations range from classic to creative, and the ability to split flavors on one pie is a plus when you are ordering for a group. For teams, church gatherings, or a house full of guests visiting New Pittsburg, it is a dependable, budget-friendly standby.