01
Best overall village pick
Snappy Tomato Pizza
Old U.S. 52 In The Village • Casual Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Small-Town Staple
Square-cut pies, generous toppings, and easy carryout make Snappy Tomato a go-to option right in New Richmond.
If you want pizza without leaving the riverfront, Snappy Tomato is the hometown standby locals default to on busy nights. The menu covers all the basics—pepperoni-heavy classics, thick cheese bakes, and build-your-own pies—along with sides that work well for sharing. It’s a straightforward, dependable choice when you need to feed a crowd fast.
02
Best for late-night delivery
Papa Johns Pizza
Old U.S. 52 Corridor • National Delivery-Focused Chain • Reliable Delivery Pick
Consistent, customizable pizzas and long hours make this Papa Johns a convenient option for delivery around New Richmond.
Located along Old U.S. 52, this Papa Johns covers a wide delivery area around the village, which is handy when you’d rather stay put. Expect the familiar lineup: create-your-own pizzas, specialty combinations, and plenty of sauces for dipping. It’s especially useful for game days and late dinners when you need something predictable and quick.
03
Best family outing
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Amelia Town Center • Family-Friendly Cincinnati-Style Pizzeria • Family-Night Favorite
A short drive from New Richmond, LaRosa’s in Amelia brings a full dine-in experience with classic Cincinnati-style pies and a big Italian menu.
If you’re up for a quick drive west, LaRosa’s in Amelia is where many east-side families head when they want pizza plus a sit-down meal. The pizzas lean classic Cincinnati-style, with a slightly sweet sauce, lots of cheese, and plenty of topping combos on offer. With pastas, salads, and kids’ options, it’s an easy pick when your group doesn’t all agree on just pizza.
04
Best small-town carryout
Grammas Pizza
Amelia Strip Along Sr 125 • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Carryout Comfort Classic
Thick cheese, hearty toppings, and a low-key feel make Grammas a comforting carryout stop within a short drive of New Richmond.
Grammas Pizza feels like the kind of place locals have been calling for years, with straightforward pies that hit the spot on low-key nights. Crusts are sturdy, toppings are generous, and the menu sticks to familiar territory—think pepperoni, sausage, and loaded deluxe options. It’s an especially good fit when you’re coming through Amelia and want a hot box to bring back toward the river.
05
Best destination pie
Joe's Pizza Napoli
Historic Downtown Milford • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Foodie-Worthy Outing
When you’re willing to drive for great pizza, Joe’s delivers charred, wood-fired Neapolitan pies in a cozy Milford setting.
Joe’s Pizza Napoli is the kind of spot New Richmond locals mention when they’re talking about making a night of it. The pizzas come out of a wood-fired oven with puffed, lightly charred crusts and thoughtful toppings that go beyond the usual chain combinations. Pair it with a walk through downtown Milford and you’ve got a worthy date night or special-occasion pizza trip.