01
Best overall pick
Left Field Pizza
In New Riegel • Family-Owned Pizzeria And Bar • Local Favorite
A lively hometown spot in New Riegel serving crowd-pleasing pies alongside burgers, sandwiches, and cold drinks.[3][4]
Left Field is a family-owned pizzeria in the village, known for a menu that goes beyond pizza to include burgers, sandwiches, and full plates.[3][4] The relaxed dining room, friendly service, and occasional trivia or live music make it an easy choice when you want a fun night out without leaving New Riegel.[4]
02
Classic local institution
Fort Ball Pizza Palace
Downtown Tiffin • Retro Sit-Down Pizza Parlor • Best For Families
Old-school booths, big trays of pizza, and a steady buzz of locals give Fort Ball a true small-town pizza-parlor feel.
Fort Ball Pizza Palace is a long-running Tiffin favorite where families pile into booths for pan-baked pizzas and classic sides. Expect a casual, slightly retro atmosphere, generous portions, and plenty of topping combinations that work just as well for dine-in as they do for a takeout night back in New Riegel.
03
Best for classic carryout
Napoli Pizza
Riverside Tiffin • No-Frills Takeout Shop • Quick Takeout Pick
Napoli leans into simple, well-made pizzas that are easy to grab on the way through Tiffin and still taste great after the drive home.
This small pizzeria keeps the focus on straightforward, well-seasoned pies with crisp edges and sturdy crusts that travel well. Call ahead, swing by to pick up your order, and you can be back in New Riegel with hot pizza before it has time to cool.
04
Best for big groups
AJ's Heavenly Pizza
South Tiffin • Casual Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Sharing
AJ's is known for hefty, sauce-forward pizzas that are ideal when you’re feeding a crowd on game night or after a long day.
AJ's Heavenly Pizza offers thickly topped pies, cheesy bread, and party-sized orders that make it an easy go-to for gatherings. Between its generous portions and flexible delivery and carryout options, it’s a smart choice when you’re hosting in New Riegel and want plenty of food with minimal fuss.
05
Reliable chain option
Marco's Pizza
West Tiffin • National Chain With Local Following • Game-Night Standby
Marco's offers consistent, customizable pizzas with crust styles and toppings that everyone at the table can agree on.
The Tiffin location of Marco's gives New Riegel residents a familiar chain option for predictable, quick pizza nights. Build your own pie or lean on their specialty combinations, add some cheesy bread or wings, and you’ve got a convenient, no-surprises spread for weeknights or last-minute gatherings.