01
Best overall pick
Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza
New Middletown • Classic Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Crisp, square-cut pies with a punchy red sauce make this the must-try stop just down the road from New Springfield.
This New Middletown outpost of a beloved Mahoning Valley mini-chain does the region’s trademark thick-yet-crisp pan pizza especially well, with caramelized edges and generous cheese. Most people call ahead and carry out, but there are a few seats if you want to dig in right away. It’s an easy choice for Friday nights, game days, and feeding a hungry crowd without overthinking it.
02
Closest quick fix
Ianazone's Pizza
New Middletown • Carryout Pizza And Wings Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
A reliable go-to for customizable pies, garlic-heavy crusts, and wings when you want something fast on the way home.
Ianazone’s leans into classic carryout comforts: sturdy crust, lots of cheese, and plenty of topping combinations, from old-school pepperoni to spicy specialty pies. The menu runs deep into wings, subs, and sides, so it works just as well for a casual family dinner as it does for a late movie-night order. Order ahead, swing through New Middletown, and you’ll be back in New Springfield with hot boxes in minutes.
03
Cozy dine-in choice
Belleria Pizzeria & Restaurant
Poland Village • Family-Friendly Italian Restaurant • Best Sit-Down Option
A relaxed Poland spot where you can linger over pizza, pasta, and baked Italian classics instead of rushing home with a box.
Belleria’s pizza tends toward a softer, saucier style, with ample cheese and a menu of familiar toppings that suits most tastes. The big draw for New Springfield folks is the sit-down experience: comfortable booths, friendly service, and a full Italian menu if someone at the table isn’t in a pizza mood. It’s a solid choice when you want a proper night out without driving all the way into downtown Youngstown.
04
Great for big groups
Cocca's Pizza Boardman
Boardman-224 Corridor • Neighborhood Pizza Chain Outpost • Best For Parties
Well-priced sheet pizzas, wings, and sides make this Boardman staple a natural pick for parties and team celebrations.
Cocca’s is built for feeding a lot of people, with sheet pizzas, bucket wings, and shareable appetizers that travel well back to New Springfield. The crust hits a middle ground between soft and crisp, with a slightly sweet sauce that wins over kids and adults alike. Call ahead for larger orders and you can stock a backyard gathering or birthday party without breaking the bank.
05
Old-school Mahoning classic
The Elmton
Struthers • Old-School Pizza And Chicken Tavern • Most Old-School Vibe
A time-warp favorite known for its baked pizza and fried chicken, worth the extra drive when you’re craving old-school charm.
The Elmton has been drawing Mahoning Valley locals for decades with its distinctive pan-baked pizza, slightly chewy crust, and well-seasoned sauce. The dining room feels like a throwback in the best way, with friendly service and a mix of regulars who treat it like a second home. Make the short trip from New Springfield when you want a leisurely sit-down meal that feels like part of the area’s food history.