01
Best in-village pick
Little Italy Pizza
New Straitsville - Main Street • Small-Town Pizzeria And Family Diner • Village Standby
The go-to New Straitsville stop for a friendly sit-down pizza night without leaving the village.
Little Italy Pizza is the kind of Main Street spot where staff know regulars by name and the pies come out generously topped. The crust leans classic rather than fancy, with plenty of cheese and a sauce that’s mild enough for kids but still satisfying for adults. It’s an easy choice when you want a relaxed meal with options beyond pizza, like subs and wings, in a no-rush setting.
02
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Logan - Downtown • Bustling Dine-In Pizza Joint • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
A Logan favorite known for generously topped pizzas and a lively, small-town sports-bar feel.
Downtown Logan’s Pizza Crossing draws both locals and Hocking Hills visitors for its thick-with-toppings pies and steady, efficient service. The menu leans into hearty combinations—think heavy cheese, plenty of pepperoni, and piled-on veggies—plus wings and appetizers for sharing. It’s an easy meet-up spot when your group wants big portions, cold drinks, and the option to linger over a game on TV.
03
Best value pick
Cristy’s Pizza
New Lexington - Near The Courthouse Square • Carryout-Focused Hometown Chain Shop • Best Value For Families
Reliable square-cut Ohio-style pizza with budget-friendly deals that work well for family nights.
Cristy’s in New Lexington turns out classic, square-cut pies with a crisp-er edge and plenty of topping coverage, ideal for feeding a crowd. It’s a carryout-first operation, so you call ahead, swing through, and bring hot boxes back to your rental, campsite, or living room. Watch for combo deals and larger sizes if you’re ordering for ball teams, sleepovers, or big family gatherings.
04
Best quick-stop option
Fox’s Pizza Den
Nelsonville - Just Off The Public Square • Quick-Service Takeout And Delivery Spot • Best For Quick Pickup On The Way Home
A convenient Nelsonville stop for big, shareable pies and fast service when you’re just passing through.
Fox’s Pizza Den in Nelsonville plays to its strengths: big pies, straightforward toppings, and quick turnaround. It’s especially handy if you’re driving back from Athens or the Hocking Hills and want to grab dinner without a sit-down stop. Go for the larger sizes or party-cut options if you’re feeding a mix of adults and kids and want something everyone will eat without debate.
05
Best post-adventure sit-down
Pizza Crossing
Nelsonville - Near Hocking College • Casual College-Town Pizzeria • Best For A Post-Hike Sit-Down
A relaxed Nelsonville offshoot of the Logan favorite, ideal for refueling after time on the trails or the river.
Nelsonville’s Pizza Crossing brings the same generous approach to toppings and hearty crust that made the Logan location famous, but with more of a college-town feel. It’s a comfortable place to crash after kayaking, hiking, or exploring the brick-lined square, with pitchers of soda, shareable appetizers, and plenty of booth space. If you like to customize, build-your-own pies and half-and-half orders make it easy to keep everyone at the table happy.