01
Best overall pick
Pizza Hut
Greenville Main Commercial Strip • Sit-Down And Carryout Chain Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Classic
A go-to for New Weston families who want familiar pan-style pizza and an easy dine-in option after a quick drive to Greenville.
If you grew up on thick, cheesy pan pizza, this is the spot that hits that nostalgic sweet spot for many Darke County locals. The menu covers the bases with build-your-own pies, stuffed crust, wings, and pasta, so everyone at the table can find something. It’s an easy choice when you want predictable quality, plenty of seating, and a low-stress dinner just outside New Weston.
02
Best for fast delivery
Domino's Pizza
Greenville Residential Fringe • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Weeknight Convenience
A reliable option when you want customizable pizza, late hours, and streamlined ordering without leaving the car for long.
Domino’s is a popular choice for New Weston residents who don’t mind the short drive but want to be in and out with hot pizza in hand. The menu leans heavily into specialty combinations, from loaded meat pies to veggie-forward options, plus pasta bowls, sandwiches, and dessert bites. Online ordering and consistent prep times make it a practical pick for busy weeknights or casual game-day spreads.
03
Best value pick
Little Caesars Pizza
Greenville Shopping Corridor • Counter-Service Takeout Spot • Budget-Friendly Favorite
Known for hot-and-ready pies, this is the grab-and-go choice when price and speed matter more than lingering over a meal.
For a lot of area families, Little Caesars is the answer when you need to feed a crowd without overthinking it. The ready-made pepperoni and cheese pizzas are ideal for last-minute team parties or movie nights back in New Weston. Add in the crazy bread, occasional limited-time specialty pies, and straightforward pricing, and it’s one of the most economical pizza runs within a short drive.
04
Best for variety
Marco's Pizza
Greenville East Side • Delivery-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Most Customizable Pies
A solid choice for those who like bolder toppings, different crust options, and a menu that goes beyond standard pepperoni.
Marco’s draws in New Weston pizza fans with its mix of classic and specialty pies, including well-seasoned pepperoni pizzas and heavier deluxe options. The crust leans toward a slightly thicker, chewy style that holds up under generous toppings. Calzones, subs, and salads round out the menu, making it easy to cover dinner for both pizza-lovers and those who want something a bit different.
05
Dayton-area favorite nearby
Cassano's Pizza King
Greenville North Side • Thin-Crust Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Classic Ohio-Style Thin Crust
A regional staple offering cracker-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings for those willing to make the short trip from New Weston.
Cassano’s brings a different style to the local mix with its signature thin, crispy crust and finely chopped toppings spread right to the edge. It’s a favorite among folks who grew up with Dayton-area pizza and still seek out that specific bite. For New Weston residents, it’s worth the extra few minutes of drive time when you’re craving something lighter and crispier than the typical pan or hand-tossed slice.