01
Best overall pick
Elliot's Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap
Downtown Newark • Wood-Fired Gastropub • Best For Date Night
Inventive wood-fired pies, a solid tap list, and a lively downtown setting make Elliot's feel like a night out, not just a quick pizza stop.
This is where Newark’s pizza feels a little bit big-city, with blistered, wood-fired crusts and toppings that go beyond the usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine. Think pies with roasted veggies, rich cheeses, and house sauces, backed up by a strong lineup of appetizers and rotating beers. It’s an easy choice for a relaxed date or catching up with friends before a show or game.
02
Beloved local chain
Christy's Pizza
North End • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Local Staple
Square-cut, edge-to-edge toppings and friendly service have made Christy's a go-to for Newark pizza cravings for years.
Christy’s leans into that signature Ohio-style thin crust, with plenty of toppings spread all the way to the edge and cut into easy-to-share squares. The menu covers all the familiar favorites plus a few specialty combinations locals swear by. It’s a dependable spot for carryout on a busy weeknight or a casual dine-in meal with the kids.
03
Old-school classic
Plaza Pizza
West Side • Old-School Carryout Shop • Best For Big Orders
Plaza Pizza delivers the no-frills, sauce-forward pies people grew up on, perfect for feeding a crowd without overthinking it.
If you like your pizza straightforward and nostalgic, Plaza Pizza is the kind of place that hits the spot. The crust stays on the thinner side, with a tangy sauce and generous cheese that feel instantly familiar. It’s especially good for game days, parties, and any time you’re calling in a couple of big boxes to keep everyone happy.
04
Delivery standout
Too Talls Pizza
South Side • Delivery-Focused Neighborhood Joint • Best For Delivery Night
Known for hearty toppings and reliable delivery, Too Talls is the spot locals dial when they want hot pizza at the door fast.
Too Talls leans into comfort-food territory, with thick layers of cheese, plenty of meat options, and crusts that hold up well to delivery. Specialty pies and build-your-own combinations make it easy to please picky eaters and adventurous friends at the same time. It’s a natural choice for movie nights, late workdays, or anytime you’d rather stay on the couch.
05
Family favorite
Pizza Cottage - Newark
East Side • Family-Friendly Pizza Restaurant • Best For Groups
With roomy seating, shareable appetizers, and a wide range of pizzas, Pizza Cottage works well for families and group get-togethers.
Pizza Cottage offers a broad menu that runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies piled high with toppings. The dining room is spacious and casual, making it easy to bring kids, teammates, or extended family without feeling cramped. Add in salads, subs, and a few crowd-pleasing sides, and you’ve got an all-around reliable option on the east side of town.