01
Best overall pick
Dina's Pizza & Pub
Old Brooklyn • Lively Sports Bar And Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Big Appetites
Huge, cheesy pies, friendly regulars, and plenty of TVs make Dina's a go-to when you want a classic Cleveland tavern pizza night.
Dina's is the kind of place where the staff learns your name and the pizza lands on the table bubbling hot with a generous blanket of cheese. The crust is sturdy enough to hold serious toppings but still has a satisfying chew, and the sweet-leaning sauce divides locals in the best possible way. It is an easy hop from Newburgh Heights and ideal for sharing big specialty pies over a game or a pitcher.
02
Artisan pie specialist
Crust
Tremont • Handcrafted, Chef-Driven Pizzeria • Best For Pizza Aficionados
Crust turns out thoughtfully topped, oversized pies with a focus on quality ingredients and a dough that fans rave about.
Set on a side street in Tremont, Crust trades in big New York–style pies with an artisan twist and a crust that hits the sweet spot between crisp and chewy. Toppings lean creative without getting fussy, with options like roasted veggies, spicy sausage, and house-made sauces. Call ahead or be ready for a wait on busy nights, but the slices reheat beautifully if you are bringing pizza back to Newburgh Heights.
03
Late-night slice standby
Edison's Pizza Kitchen
Tremont • Casual Slice Shop And Bar • Late-Night Favorite
Edison's is where you wander in after a night out and walk away with a greasy, satisfying slice on a paper plate.
This Tremont staple keeps things simple: big rectangular pies, plenty of cheese and pepperoni, and a vibe that says come as you are. The crust is on the thicker side with crisp edges, perfect for soaking up a few drinks from nearby bars. It is not fancy, but when you need a reliable late-night option a short drive from Newburgh Heights, Edison's delivers exactly what you're craving.
04
Wood-fired standout
Citizen Pie
Ohio City • Neapolitan-Style Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Best For Quick, High-Heat Pies
Citizen Pie dishes out blistered, airy-crusted pizzas from a roaring wood-fired oven in just a couple of minutes.
If you like your pizza with leopard-spotted crust and a soft, tender center, Citizen Pie is worth the short drive from Newburgh Heights. The menu leans Italian with simple combinations that let the dough, fresh mozzarella, and San Marzano–style sauce shine. Counter service keeps things moving fast, making it a smart choice before a night out in Ohio City or a quick lunch run.
05
Classic Cleveland slices
Geraci's Slice Shop
Ohio City • Retro Slice Shop • Best For Nostalgic Flavors
Geraci's Slice Shop serves foldable slices built on a decades-old family recipe that many Clevelanders grew up with.
This offshoot of the longtime Geraci's restaurant brings that familiar Cleveland red-sauce-and-cheese comfort to a grab-and-go slice counter. Expect a slightly sweet sauce, plenty of melty cheese, and a crust sturdy enough to fold on the go. It is a fun stop when you are bouncing between Ohio City spots and want a quick, satisfying taste of a local institution not far from Newburgh Heights.