01
Best quick delivery
Domino's Pizza
Downtown Newcomerstown • Carryout-First National Chain • Fast, Familiar Option
The go-to when you want hot, predictable pizza delivered anywhere in the village without much waiting.
Domino's in downtown Newcomerstown is the reliable weeknight move, especially if you are feeding a crowd on short notice. The menu hits all the chain favorites, from hand-tossed and pan pizzas to wings and stuffed cheesy bread. Order ahead for game nights or road-trip stops and you will have dinner boxed up and ready when you roll through town.
02
Destination pie road trip
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Wood-Fired Artisan Pizzeria • Worth The Drive For Food Lovers
A polished, small-town pizzeria known county-wide for its chewy crusts, creative toppings, and lively dining room.
Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek is the place locals mention when they talk about making a night of it. Expect a slightly charred, flavorful crust, quality cheeses, and toppings that go well beyond the basic pepperoni and sausage. It is an easy drive from Newcomerstown and works just as well for a casual date night as it does for a family dinner after a day exploring Amish Country.
03
Classic Tuscarawas favorite
Penso's Pizza
Gnadenhutten Village Center • Old-School Ohio Pizzeria • Best For Nostalgic, Sauce-Heavy Pies
A local standby turning out sturdy, square-cut pies with plenty of cheese and a tangy red sauce.
Penso's in Gnadenhutten feels like the kind of neighborhood pizza shop every small town should have. The crust leans toward soft and foldable, with generous cheese and a sweet-leaning sauce that hits all the classic Ohio pizza notes. Call ahead for carryout on busy nights, then take your boxes back toward Newcomerstown or down to the river for an easy picnic meal.
04
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza
West Lafayette Strip • Casual Buffet-Style Chain • Family-Friendly And Flexible
A laid-back spot where you can mix pan, thin, and specialty pizzas with salads and sides to please a whole crew.
The East of Chicago in West Lafayette is a handy choice when everyone in the group wants something different. You can build your own thick, saucy pan pizza, go lighter with thin crust, or let the kitchen handle it with one of their loaded specialty pies. It is an easy hop from Newcomerstown and works well for teams, youth groups, or family gatherings where quantity and variety matter as much as anything.
05
Familiar pan pizza fix
Pizza Hut
Coshocton Retail Corridor • Sit-Down Pan-Pizza Chain • Best For Dine-In Comfort
A classic stop for buttery pan pizza, breadsticks, and a relaxed booth after errands in Coshocton.
When you are already in Coshocton and want something predictable, Pizza Hut scratches that nostalgic pan-pizza itch. The thick, crispy-edged crust and familiar toppings make it an easy choice for families with picky eaters. Grab a booth, linger over a pitcher of soda, and you have a low-key meal before heading back toward Newcomerstown.