01
Best overall pick
Keyhole Pizza
Fort Loramie Near Lake Loramie • Lively Small-Town Pizzeria And Bar • Local Favorite For Groups
A buzzy Fort Loramie staple known for generous toppings, cold beer, and a busy dining room on game nights.
Keyhole is the place locals name first when you ask where to grab pizza around Newport. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, and the menu runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies. It is a natural stop after a day at Lake Loramie or on the way back to Newport.
02
Best for takeout
Sandy's Pizza
Fort Loramie Village Center • Family-Run Carryout Pizza Shop • Best For Big Takeout Orders
A long-running Fort Loramie shop turning out square-cut party pizzas that travel well back to Newport.
Sandy's leans into the classic small-town carryout vibe, with friendly counter service and pizza boxes stacked high on busy nights. The pies are cut in squares, making them easy to share with a crowd or pack up for a casual get-together. Call ahead on weekends, as locals tend to order early and often.
03
Best thin-crust option
Cassano's Pizza King
Sidney North Side • Classic Dayton-Style Pizza Joint • Go-To Spot For Thin-Crust Fans
A regional staple serving thin, crispy-crust pizzas piled with edge-to-edge toppings.
If you like your crust on the crisp side, Cassano's in Sidney is worth the short drive from Newport. Their Dayton-style pies are cut into small squares with toppings spread all the way to the edge, so every bite gets some crunch. It is a good pick when you want something a step up from standard chain pizza but still fast and familiar.
04
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Sidney Commercial Strip • Fast-Delivery National Pizza Chain • Reliable Late-Night Delivery
A dependable choice for customizable pizzas and sides when you want fast delivery out toward Newport.
Domino's in Sidney is the workhorse option for nights when convenience matters more than atmosphere. With online ordering, frequent deals, and a wide range of crusts and toppings, it is easy to feed a group without much planning. It is especially handy for late-night cravings when smaller local shops have already closed.
05
Best sit-down chain
Pizza Hut
Sidney Retail Corridor • Casual Sit-Down Pan-Pizza Restaurant • Good Choice For Dine-In With Kids
A familiar spot for pan pizzas, breadsticks, and a relaxed booth-and-soda-fountain kind of meal.
Sidney's Pizza Hut makes sense when you want a simple, family-friendly dine-in option near Newport. The signature pan crust and stuffed crust pizzas are crowd-pleasers, and the menu has enough pasta and wings to keep non-pizza eaters happy. It is an easy place to linger over a pitcher of soda and a couple of pies after errands in town.