01
Best overall pick
Tiger Den Pizza
East Broad Street In Downtown Newton Falls • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In And Carryout
A cozy Broad Street shop turning out generously topped pies that feel tailor-made for small-town pizza night.[4][5]
Tiger Den sits right on East Broad Street and feels like the kind of place where the staff learns your order after a few visits.[4] Expect a crisp-but-chewy crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that lean classic rather than experimental.[5] It is the spot locals suggest when you want a relaxed booth, a hot pie out of the oven, and a familiar, hometown vibe.[4][5]
02
Classic carryout choice
Sam's Pizza Shop
South Canal Street Commercial Strip • Old-School Takeout Pizza Shop • Best For Big, Shareable Pies
A no-frills Canal Street staple known for hearty, affordable pizzas built to feed a crowd.[2][3][5]
Sam's Pizza Shop on South Canal Street leans fully into the classic carryout model: phone in an order, swing by, and head home with a box that fills the whole kitchen table.[2] The pies tend to be saucy, cheesy, and cut to share, with sturdy crusts that stand up well to extra toppings and a car ride.[3][5] It is an easy go-to for family gatherings, game nights, or any time you need a lot of pizza without overthinking it.[2][5]
03
Regional chain favorite
Gionino's Pizzeria
North Side Of Newton Falls • Regional-Chain Carryout Spot • Reliable Carryout Option
A Gionino's outpost bringing the regional chain's recognizable crust and toppings lineup to the Newton Falls area.[5]
Gionino's Pizzeria gives Newton Falls residents a taste of a well-known Northeast Ohio chain without a long drive.[5] The menu usually covers the basics—pepperoni, deluxe, white pies—plus crowd-pleasing extras like chicken and jojo potatoes, making it easy to satisfy different tastes in one order.[5] It is a solid pick when you want familiar flavors, consistent preparation, and quick carryout or delivery.
04
Most convenient delivery
Domino's Pizza
West Broad Street Gateway • Fast-Delivery National Chain • Late-Night And Game-Day Favorite
The West Broad Street Domino's handles the classic national-chain playbook: fast online ordering, predictable pies, and late-night delivery.[1][6]
Set on West Broad Street, the Newton Falls Domino's is all about convenience, from the app-based ordering to frequent deals on multiple pizzas and sides.[1] While it is not trying to be artisanal, the build-your-own options and specialty pies make it easy to customize a box for your crew.[1][6] Think of it as the dependable choice for last-minute cravings, busy weeknights, or when you want food at your door by kickoff.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren, A Short Drive West • Classic Tavern-Style Pizza And Pub • Destination Pick For A Night Out
A longtime Warren institution serving crisp, tavern-style pies that many Trumbull County locals are happy to drive over from Newton Falls for.
If you are up for a short drive, Sunrise Inn in downtown Warren is one of those old-school spots where the pizza feels as much a part of the local story as the building itself. The pies are typically thinner and crisper, with well-browned cheese and toppings that go right to the edge, making them perfect for sharing over a couple of drinks. It is a smart choice when you want to turn pizza into a full night out rather than just a quick takeout run.