Newtown sits in a sweet spot on Cincinnati’s east side, with a mix of small-town charm and easy access to serious pizza talent. Within a short drive you can find everything from casual game-day slices to carefully blistered Neapolitan pies. Use this list to plan your next low-key night out or a mini pizza tour without straying far from Newtown.
Laid-back pies, cold beer, and a true Newtown crowd on Main Street.
NVT Pizza & Brew feels like the village living room, with plenty of locals grabbing a pie and a pint after work or ball games. The pizzas lean classic and hearty, with generous toppings and a crust that holds up well for sharing. It’s an easy first choice when you want good pizza without leaving Newtown proper.
Thick, crispy-edged Detroit-style squares with creative toppings just down the hill from Newtown.
Taglio’s Columbia-Tusculum location is a quick hop from Newtown and worth the short drive for its golden-edged, pan-baked pies. The crust is airy inside, crisp on the outside, and built to handle bold toppings and sauces. It’s the spot to try something a little different when you’ve had your fill of standard rounds.
Big, foldable New York slices with a classic corner-pizzeria feel in Mt. Lookout Square.
Ramundo’s is the place to go when you want a giant, no-nonsense slice without a lot of ceremony. The crust has that ideal balance of chew and crisp, and the topping combinations range from simple cheese to loaded specialties. It’s perfect for quick bites before or after a night out, and still close enough to Newtown for an easy detour.
Creative specialty pies and an open kitchen that keeps kids entertained and adults well-fed.
Dewey’s in Oakley combines a bustling dining room with inventive pizzas that go beyond the usual pepperoni and sausage. From white pies to loaded veggie combinations, the menu keeps everyone at the table interested, and the kitchen show helps pass the time. It’s a reliable choice for Newtown families looking to make a night of it after shopping or errands on the east side.
Delicate, blistered Neapolitan pies that feel straight out of a pizza-obsessed Italian side street.
Joe’s Pizza Napoli in Milford is a bit of a pilgrimage from Newtown, but pizza fans regularly make the trip. The dough is fermented for flavor, then fired quickly in a hot oven to produce a soft, leopard-spotted crust with simple, high-quality toppings. Save this one for nights when you want to slow down, share a couple of pies, and appreciate the details.