01
Village staple since the ’90s
Cardinal's Pizza
Village Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Go-To In The Village
The classic North Lewisburg stop for loaded pies, subs, and wings when you want something close and comforting.
Cardinal's is the kind of small-town pizza shop where everyone seems to know the specials by heart. The crust is on the heartier side, with generous cheese and toppings that make a large pie easy to split with a crowd. It’s an easy first choice when you want to stay in the village but still feel like you treated yourself.
02
Destination wood-fired pies
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Neapolitan-Style Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Destination
Award-winning, high-heat pies with blistered crusts and creative toppings in a lively downtown Bellefontaine setting.
Six Hundred Downtown draws pizza fans from well beyond Logan and Champaign counties for its carefully made, competition-level pies. Expect a soft, chewy crust with char from the wood-fired oven and topping combos that go far beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. It’s the spot you pick when you’re willing to drive a bit for a sit-down pizza night that feels like an occasion.
03
Big-group crowd pleaser
Benny's Pizza
North Marysville • Lively Sports Bar And Pizza Patio • Best For Big Groups And Families
A Marysville favorite for shareable pizzas, cold drinks, and plenty of space to spread out, especially when the patio is open.
Benny's leans into the fun side of pizza night, with roomy seating, TVs, and a menu that covers classic pies, loaded specialty pizzas, and plenty of sides. The crust is sturdy enough to hold lots of toppings, which makes their deluxe and meat-heavy options especially popular. It’s an ideal choice when you’re meeting friends halfway between North Lewisburg and Columbus or need a place that can handle a whole team after a game.
04
Crispy-edge classic
Donatos Pizza
East Urbana • Classic Ohio Thin-Crust Chain • Reliable Weeknight Option
Crisp, edge-to-edge thin crust pizzas that are easy to customize and just as easy to grab on the way home.
The Urbana Donatos is a go-to when you want something familiar: ultra-thin crust, toppings spread right to the edge, and predictable timing for carryout or delivery. The pepperoni and Serious Cheese are local standbys, but the menu also covers lighter veggie pies and oven-baked subs. It’s a practical, no-surprises option that works just as well for a quick weeknight dinner as it does for feeding a small group back in North Lewisburg.
05
Local-style takeout favorite
Heavenly Pizza
South Urbana • Family-Run Takeout Shop • Budget-Friendly Crowd Pleaser
Hearty, saucy pies with generous cheese and toppings, made for carryout nights and casual gatherings.
Heavenly Pizza has the feel of a classic Ohio neighborhood shop, with slightly thicker crusts, plenty of sauce, and toppings that don’t skimp. Combination pies and square-cut party trays make it easy to feed a group without spending a fortune. If you’re heading back toward North Lewisburg from Urbana and want a hot box in the passenger seat, this is an easy detour.