01
Best overall pick
Wedgewood Pizza Boardman
Boardman - South Avenue • Classic Youngstown-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to for thick, cheesy Youngstown-style pies with serious hometown cred.
Ask almost anyone in the area for a pizza recommendation and Wedgewood’s Boardman shop comes up fast. The pies are hearty, with a crisp-but-doughy crust, tangy red sauce, and generous toppings that feel built for sharing. It’s the place you call when you want a crowd-pleasing sheet pizza for family, friends, or the big game.
02
Classic slice stop
Cornersburg Pizza Boardman
Boardman - Western Reserve Road • Neighborhood Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Old-School Flavor
A no-frills counter spot turning out square-cut pies with a loyal local following.
Cornersburg’s Boardman location feels like the kind of place locals grow up on: simple, busy, and focused on the pizza. The crust leans on the thicker side, with a well-seasoned sauce and edge-to-edge cheese that works especially well on pepperoni or sausage. It’s a great option when you want a classic, comfort-style Mahoning Valley pie to bring back to the house.
03
Best for carryout and delivery
Cocca's Pizza Boardman
Boardman - Market Street Corridor • Takeout-First Neighborhood Shop • Reliable Weeknight Pick
A local mini-chain known for consistent pies, plenty of topping combos, and easy ordering.
Cocca’s Boardman shop is a dependable choice when you need pizza on the table without much fuss. The crust is a bit lighter than some Youngstown-style spots, with a sweet-leaning sauce and well-balanced cheese that holds up nicely in the box. Between their specialty pies, classic pepperoni, and kid-friendly options, it’s a solid move for busy weeknights near North Lima.
04
Best game-day hangout
Inner Circle Pizza Poland
Poland Village • Sports Bar With Serious Pizza • Best For Groups
Lively bar-style spot where crispy, cheese-loaded pies share the spotlight with the game on TV.
Inner Circle in Poland feels built for wings, cold beer, and pizza with friends, but the pies stand on their own. The crust is thinner and crisper than many nearby shops, with a nice char and plenty of cheese that pairs well with their classic toppings. It’s a fun choice when you want to make an evening of it rather than just grab a box and go.
05
Best for families
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant Boardman
Boardman - U.S. 224 Strip • Italian Family Restaurant And Pizzeria • Sit-Down Favorite
A sit-down Italian spot where the pizza shares the menu with pastas, salads, and red-sauce classics.
Belleria’s Boardman dining room is ideal when some people want pizza and others want a full Italian dinner. The pizzas come with a soft, substantial crust, a robust sauce, and toppings that skew traditional—think sausage, peppers, and mushrooms. It’s an easy pick for family dinners, casual celebrations, or anyone who wants a slice followed by a plate of pasta.