01
Best overall pick
Zeppe's Perry
Along North Ridge Road In Perry • Classic Takeout Pizzeria • Reliable Local Favorite
A go-to spot for well-built, customizable pies that please just about everyone at the table.
Zeppe's Perry is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for Friday nights and quick family dinners. The crust is sturdy without being heavy, toppings are generous, and the menu stretches from straightforward cheese and pepperoni to specialty combinations. It is also one of the most convenient options when you want pizza, wings, and a salad in one easy stop.
02
Neighborhood staple
Capp's Pizza
Village Of Perry • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Big Orders
Dependable, crowd-pleasing pizzas with hearty toppings that work well for families and teams.
Capp's Pizza leans into old-school, Ohio-style pies with a focus on value and consistency. The sauce is slightly sweet, the cheese pull is generous, and classic toppings like sausage and pepperoni come piled on. It is a smart choice when you are feeding a ball team, hosting a birthday, or just want a stack of boxes that everyone will be happy to open.
03
Sit-down standout
Joey's Italian Grille
Madison On Route 20 • Italian Grill With Full Bar • Best Sit-Down Option
A comfortable spot where you can pair a well-made pizza with pasta, apps, and a drink without rushing.
Joey's Italian Grille is worth the short drive when you want more than quick carryout. The pizza comes with a nicely browned crust and balanced sauce, and you can round out the table with wings, calamari, or a pasta dish. It works equally well for a relaxed date night or a family dinner where everyone wants something a little different.
04
Brick-oven favorite
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza
Madison Near Downtown • Brick-Oven Neighborhood Spot • Best For Creative Toppings
Chewy, flavorful crust and fun topping combinations make these pies stand out for pizza fans who like to try something new.
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza leans into a slightly more artisan feel, with crust that crisps up nicely while staying chewy at the center. Beyond the classics, you will find specialty pies with interesting sauces and toppings that reward repeat visits. It is a great option when you are in the mood to branch out from your usual pepperoni-and-cheese routine.
05
Game-day go-to
Bada Bing Pizza
Just Off I-90 In Madison • Sports-Bar-Style Pizza Joint • Best For Wings And Pies
Lively, sauce-forward pies and meaty wings make this a natural choice for watching the game or grabbing takeout.
Bada Bing Pizza brings a little more energy, with bold flavors and a menu built around sharing. The pizzas tend to be saucier and cheesier, ideal for those who like a fuller, more indulgent slice. Add an order of wings or garlic breadsticks and you have an easy spread for game night or a casual get-together with friends.