01
Best overall pick
Siciley Pizza
North Randall – Warrensville Center Road • Compact Counter-Service Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Delivery And Takeout
A small, no-frills shop turning out generous, well-topped pies right in the heart of North Randall.
Siciley Pizza is the kind of neighborhood spot that keeps North Randall fed on busy weeknights and game days, with reliably hot pies and fast service. The menu leans classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and meat lovers—but you’ll also find loaded specialty pizzas and hearty sides like wings and fries. It’s strictly casual and mostly takeout, but for anyone staying nearby, this is the closest thing to a go-to house slice.
02
Classic Cleveland institution
Geraci's Restaurant
University Heights – Warrensville Center Corridor • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Nostalgic, Red-Sauce Comfort
A beloved east-side standby known for its crisp-edged, cheesy pies and classic family-restaurant vibe.
A short drive north up Warrensville Center Road lands you at Geraci’s, a Cleveland-area fixture serving the kind of pizza many locals grew up on. The crust is thin but sturdy, with a generous blanket of cheese that bakes up golden and a little bit caramelized at the edges. Pair a pie with a salad and a red-sauce pasta, settle into a booth, and you’ve got a low-key night out that feels satisfyingly old-school.
03
Campus-area crowd-pleaser
Rascal House – University Heights
University Heights – Near John Carroll University • Casual Fast-Casual Pizza And Wings Spot • Best For Big Slices And Late Nights
A lively, student-favorite joint with oversized slices, shareable pies, and plenty of snacks for groups.
Just north of North Randall, Rascal House caters to students and families alike with thick, cheesy pies, big wedges, and a long list of fried appetizers. The crust runs on the heartier side, built to hold lots of toppings and survive a ride home without getting soggy. It’s a handy choice when you’ve got a mixed crowd—there’s enough variety on the menu that everyone can find something, and it works as well for delivery as it does for an informal sit-down meal.
04
Neighborhood artisan pick
La Pecora Pizzeria
Cleveland – Larchmere District • Creative, Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Best For Inventive Toppings And Date Nights
A stylish Larchmere spot turning out blistered, wood-fired pies with thoughtful toppings and seasonal touches.
La Pecora sits just west of Shaker Square, close enough to be an easy destination from North Randall when you want something a bit more polished. The pizzas arrive with chewy, leopard-spotted crusts and well-balanced toppings that lean more farmers-market than takeout chain. It’s the kind of place where you linger over a pie, share a couple of small plates, and make an evening out of your pizza run.
05
True Neapolitan experience
Vero Pizza Napoletana
Cleveland Heights – Cedar-Fairmount • Authentic Neapolitan Pizzeria • Best For Purists And Pizza Aficionados
A focused, wood-fired operation known for soft-centered pies, simple toppings, and a serious approach to dough.
Up in Cedar-Fairmount, Vero offers a very different take from the typical delivery pie, with a soft, foldable center and airy, charred edges straight from a blazing-hot oven. The menu keeps things tight and traditional—Margherita, marinara, and a handful of carefully composed specials that let the dough, tomatoes, and mozzarella shine. It’s a bit of a pilgrimage from North Randall, but for anyone who obsesses over crust and craft, it’s more than worth the drive.