01
Best overall pick
Jolly's Pizza- North Royalton
Royalton Road Corridor • Brewpub-Style Pizzeria • Best For Lingering Over A Pint And A Pie
Craft beer, creative pies, and a warm, buzzy room make Jolly’s the place many locals think of first.
Jolly’s combines a full in-house brewery with a focused pizza menu, so you can pair a crisp house IPA with a white pie or a loaded meat combo without overthinking it. The crust hits a nice middle ground between chewy and crisp, with toppings that lean generous rather than fussy. It’s a great call when you want a proper night out but still keep things casual and local.
02
Best for custom pies
My Pizzetta - North Royalton
Near State Road Plazas • Fast-Casual Build-Your-Own Spot • Best For Quick, Personal Pizzas
My Pizzetta specializes in fast-fired, personal pies where you call the shots on every topping.
Here, the focus is on individual pizzas baked in a high-heat oven, so everyone at the table can design exactly what they want and still eat at the same time. The process is straightforward: pick your dough, sauce, cheeses, and toppings, then watch it bake in just a few minutes. It’s a smart option for weeknights, mixed dietary needs, or anyone who is picky about their perfect pizza ratio.
03
Classic local staple
Augie's Pizza
State Road Strip • Classic Family Pizzeria • Family Go-To
Augie’s is the kind of long-running pizza shop people grow up on and keep coming back to.
Expect a straightforward, comforting pie with a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings done well. The menu stretches beyond pizza to ribs and other crowd-pleasers, which makes it easy to feed a mixed group or a hungry team after a game. It’s less about trends and more about reliable, satisfying takeout that feels very North Royalton.
04
Reliable chain favorite
Zeppe's North Royalton
Ridge Road Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Weeknight Delivery Standby
Zeppe’s delivers classic, pile-it-on pizzas with plenty of options for wings, subs, and more on the side.
This is a go-to when you want a big, shareable pizza night at home without overcomplicating the order. The crust leans toward the hearty side, built to hold generous toppings and extra cheese, and the menu offers enough variety to keep everyone happy. It’s especially handy for last-minute game nights or feeding a crowd with minimal planning.
05
Best pizza-in-a-pub setting
Tony Maloney's Pub & Pizza
Royalton Town Center Area • Lively Pub With Pizza • Best For Game-Day Crowds
Tony Maloney’s pairs hearty, pub-style pizzas with a full bar and plenty of televisions for catching the game.
The pizzas here are built for sharing at a high-top: sturdy crust, lots of cheese, and toppings that match well with a cold beer. It’s loud, friendly, and relaxed, the kind of place where locals linger over a pie while watching the Browns or Cavs. If you want pizza plus a proper bar vibe rather than a dedicated pizzeria experience, this is the move.