01
Best overall pick
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Maple Avenue Corridor • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Local Landmark
A classic Zanesville institution known for sweet-sauce pies, generous cheese, and lively family energy.[6][7]
Adornetto's is the spot many locals name first when you ask where to get pizza in Zanesville.[6][7] The crust lands in that satisfying middle ground—neither cracker-thin nor heavy—topped with a slightly sweet red sauce and plenty of cheese.[7] Expect a busy dining room on weekends, along with a nostalgic red-sauce-Italian vibe that makes it easy to linger over dinner with family or friends.[7]
02
Best for carryout
Creno's Pizza - Maple Ave
North Maple Avenue • Classic Takeout Pizzeria • Go-To For Quick Pickup
Creno's on Maple Avenue is a no-fuss favorite for hefty, edge-to-edge-topped pies ready for pickup or delivery.[2][6]
This Creno's location sits right along the main strip locals use to hop between North Zanesville and town, making it an easy swing-by on busy weeknights.[2] The pizza leans hearty, with a soft, bready crust, assertive cheese, and toppings spread right to the rim so every slice feels loaded.[6] Pair it with their wings or cheesy bread and you’ve got an affordable crowd-pleaser for game nights and casual get-togethers.[2][6]
03
Best delivery standby
Four Star Pizza & Subs - North
Linden Avenue • Neighborhood Pizza And Sub Shop • Reliable Delivery Pick
Four Star’s north-side shop on Linden Avenue turns out classic pizzas and subs with fast delivery that covers North Zanesville and beyond.[3][6]
If you want an easy, predictable order that feeds a mixed crowd, Four Star is a strong bet.[3] The menu runs well beyond pizza into subs and sides, but the pies themselves are sturdy, saucy, and built to travel—ideal when you’re calling in from home, a hotel, or a youth tournament.[3][6] Deals and multi-pizza specials pop up often, so it’s worth checking what’s on offer before you place a big order.[3]
04
Best neighborhood hangout
Tat's Pizzeria
West Pike Corridor • Casual Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Laid-Back Nights Out
Tat's feels like the kind of low-key neighborhood shop where staff remembers your usual and the pizza tastes straight from someone’s home oven.[6]
A favorite among locals willing to drive a few extra minutes from North Zanesville, Tat's is praised for friendly service and consistently well-baked pies.[6] The crust has a satisfying chew, with toppings and cheese kept in balance rather than piled on just for size.[6] With TVs, cold drinks, and a relaxed pace, it’s a comfortable spot to linger over a pie instead of rushing back to the car.[6]
05
Best for big groups
Pizza Cottage - Zanesville
Northpointe / Shopping Area • Spacious Family Pizza Restaurant • Team And Family Gathering Spot
Pizza Cottage’s Zanesville outpost pairs crowd-pleasing pizza with a roomy dining area that works well for teams, parties, and big family tables.[8][6]
This regional favorite brings a slightly more modern feel than the old-line parlors closer to downtown, with plenty of space to spread out.[8] Expect a wide range of specialty pies, from loaded-meat options to veggie-forward combinations, along with salads and appetizers that make it easy to feed a group.[8] Its location near major roads and shopping makes it a convenient meeting point when you’re coming from different parts of Muskingum County.[8][6]