Obetz may be small, but it sits within easy reach of some seriously satisfying pizza. From a no-frills counter that locals swear by to old-school tavern pies and lively sports-bar slices, the south side of Columbus has plenty to explore. These five spots offer a mix of classic Columbus-style, hearty carryout, and neighborhood hangouts worth the short drive.
A cozy Obetz original turning out hearty, topping-loaded pies that locals grow up on.
Possum Holler Pizza feels exactly like the kind of low-key shop every small town hopes it has. The menu leans classic, with generous cheese, sturdy crust, and plenty of meat-heavy combinations that hold up well for carryout. It is the spot Obetz residents call first for Friday nights, team parties, and family movie marathons.
A Groveport landmark known for thin, edge-to-edge tavern-style pizzas in a laid-back, wood-paneled space.
Just a short hop from Obetz, Plank's On Broadway is the kind of neighborhood institution people drive across town for. The pizza is classic Columbus tavern-style: a thin, crispy crust, square cut, and covered corner to corner with toppings and cheese. Go for a pitcher and a loaded pie, then linger over the old-school bar vibe and small-town main street setting.
A south-side favorite for customizable pies, big salads, and subs that make feeding a crowd easy.
Flyers in Groveport hits the sweet spot between local feel and dialed-in consistency. The crust is slightly thicker than classic tavern style, with a good chew that stands up to plenty of toppings and extra cheese. It is a go-to for youth teams, big family orders, and casual weeknight dinners when you want pizza, wings, and subs all from one place.
Classic Columbus-style pizza served alongside wings, cold beer, and plenty of TV screens.
A quick drive southeast lands you at Massey's in Canal Winchester, where pizza and sports are very much the main event. Expect the signature Columbus-style crust—crispy at the edges, cut in squares—with lots of pepperoni cups and edge-to-edge toppings. It is ideal when you want to watch the game with friends, split a few specialty pies, and work through a basket or two of wings.
A beloved east-side spot known for hefty, flavor-packed pies and slices that reward the drive from Obetz.
Bexley Pizza Plus is a little farther north but firmly in the conversation for some of the area's best pies. The pizzas are substantial, with a thicker, chewy crust, bold sauce, and creative specialty combos that travel well for takeout back to Obetz. It is the place to try when you are ready to branch out from your usual order and make a mini pizza field trip of it.