01
Best overall pick
Wally's Pizza
Southgate Parkway Corridor, Cambridge • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A longstanding Cambridge staple where big, cheesy pies and friendly service make it worth the drive from Old Washington.
Wally's is the kind of independently owned shop locals grow up on, with well-loaded pizzas, crispy crusts, and generous portions. The menu leans classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and specialty combos—but everything is done with care and consistency. It is an easy choice when you want a sit-down pie that still feels very much like Guernsey County.
02
Top delivery option
Domino's Pizza Cambridge
East Cambridge • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Delivery To Old Washington
For late-night or game-day cravings, Domino's in Cambridge is the reliable choice that actually delivers out toward Old Washington.
If convenience is the priority, Domino's offers the broadest delivery reach and online ordering that makes planning easy. You can build-your-own or lean on their specialty pies, plus round things out with wings and sandwiches for a crowd. It is not fancy, but for many Old Washington residents it is the go-to option when cooking is off the table.
03
Best family night spot
Pizza Hut Cambridge
I-70/77 Interchange Area, Cambridge • Sit-Down Red-Roof Classic • Best For Families
A familiar dine-in Pizza Hut where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and roomy booths make it easy to wrangle a family meal.
This Cambridge location keeps the classic Pizza Hut feel, with table service, shareable appetizers, and plenty of space for kids. The pan and stuffed-crust pies are the stars, and there are enough toppings and crust options to keep everyone at the table happy. It is a solid pick when you want a simple, predictable night out without driving too far from Old Washington.
04
Worth-the-drive destination
Pizza Cottage Zanesville
North Zanesville • Modern Regional Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Teams
A lively regional chain known for its crisp-edged pies, big dining room, and crowd-pleasing menu just up the road in Zanesville.
Pizza Cottage serves up thin-to-medium crust pizzas loaded with toppings, alongside salads, subs, and appetizers that make feeding a group straightforward. The Zanesville location is roomy and casual, with plenty of tables and a pace that works well for teams, birthday gatherings, or extended family. It is a bit of a drive from Old Washington, but many locals make the trip when they want pizza to feel like an outing.
05
Classic Italian institution
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Old-School Italian Restaurant • Best For A Night Out
A decades-old Zanesville favorite where thin, cheesy pizzas share the spotlight with hearty Italian comfort food.
Adornetto's has the cozy, lived-in feel of a place that has hosted generations of family dinners and post-game celebrations. The pizzas come with a slightly sweet sauce and plenty of cheese, and you can pair them with pastas, salads, and house specialties if you want a fuller meal. For Old Washington residents willing to make a proper evening of it, this is the spot that feels like a small-town classic worth dressing up for.