01
Best overall pick
Angelina's Pizza
Olmsted Township • Classic Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Local Staple For Carryout And Delivery
A go-to shop for generously topped, classic pies just minutes from downtown Olmsted Falls.
Angelina's is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial: reliable, quick, and consistently satisfying. The crust skews classic Midwest—sturdy but not too thick—piled high with cheese and toppings. It’s an easy choice when you want familiar flavors, big portions, and smooth pickup or delivery after a busy day.
02
Best for modern craft pies
Doughluxe Pizza
North Olmsted - Lorain Road • Modern Craft Pizzeria With Bar • Best For Inventive Toppings And Date Night
A polished spot that leans into creative combinations and quality ingredients without feeling fussy.
Doughluxe Pizza caters to pizza fans who like a little flair with their slice, turning out well-charred pies with thoughtfully layered toppings. Expect combinations that go beyond basic pepperoni—think specialty meats, fresh veggies, and drizzles that actually add something. It’s a comfortable choice for a casual date, a small group, or anyone who wants a sit-down pizza night instead of straight takeout.
03
Best for families
Giovanni's Pizza
North Olmsted - Great Northern Area • Casual Family Pizzeria • Best For Families And Big Appetites
Hearty, crowd-pleasing pizzas and Italian comfort food that work well for feeding a group.
Giovanni's leans into comfort, serving substantial pies with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese. It’s the kind of place where a couple of large pizzas, a salad, and some wings will easily cover a family or game-night spread. If you’re driving over from Olmsted Falls with kids in tow, the straightforward menu and generous portions make planning easy.
04
Best game-day option
Romeo's Pizza
North Olmsted - Retail Strip • Busy Regional Delivery And Carryout Shop • Game-Day Delivery Favorite
A reliable chain outpost known for bold flavors, specialty pies, and efficient delivery.
Romeo's is built for those nights when you want pizza that feels a little indulgent and you want it fast. The menu leans heavy on specialty pies with kicked-up sauces, loaded toppings, and options like thick-cut pepperoni or sweeter red sauce. It’s a smart pick when you’re hosting a watch party in Olmsted Falls and want something more interesting than basic chain pizza without overthinking the order.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo
Strongsville - Pearl Road Corridor • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Classic Cleveland-Style Pies
A long-running local mini-chain turning out saucy, cheese-forward pies that feel rooted in the region.
Antonio's is a familiar name on the west side, and the Strongsville location is an easy hop for Olmsted Falls pizza fans. Expect that unmistakable Cleveland-style touch: a slightly crispy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a sauce that leans just a bit sweet. It’s a great option when you’re already out running errands toward Strongsville and want to bring a tried-and-true pie home for dinner.