01
Best overall pick
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren • Old-School Italian Tavern With Signature Pan Pizza • Local Favorite
A Trumbull County institution known for thick, cheesy pies and a lively, old-school dining room.
If you ask around Orangeville where to drive for a “real” pizza night, Sunrise Inn is the name that comes up first. Their thick, edge-to-edge cheese pies and Brier Hill-style pizzas are the kind of stick-to-your-ribs comfort food this part of Ohio is known for. Plan on a bit of a wait on weekends, but the generous portions and classic neighborhood-bar atmosphere make it worth the drive.
02
Best for classic red-sauce night
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria
Downtown Warren • Casual Pizzeria And Italian Restaurant • Classic Downtown Stop
Thin, bubbly-crust pizzas and red-sauce favorites in a comfortable downtown setting.
Avalon Downtown is a solid choice when you want pizza plus the option of pasta, wings, and a glass of wine or beer. Their pizzas lean thinner with a crisp bottom and nicely browned cheese, making them easy to share alongside an antipasto or salad. It is a good spot if you are spending the evening in Warren or meeting friends from around the county.
03
Best for big groups
Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Hubbard • Family-Friendly Italian Spot With Hearty Pizza • Best For Families And Teams
Hearty trays of pizza, pasta, and wings that make feeding a crowd straightforward and affordable.
Just down the road in Hubbard, Belleria is a go-to when you are wrangling kids, cousins, or a ball team after a game. The crust is on the thicker side, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the menu has enough non-pizza options to keep everyone happy. Call ahead for sheet pizzas and large orders if you are coming from Orangeville with a group.
04
Best nearby takeout
Ianazone's Pizza
Brookfield & Vienna Area • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Go-To For Quick Pickup
Reliable, generously topped pies that are easy to grab on the way home through Brookfield or Vienna.
For many Orangeville households, Ianazone's is the weeknight standby when nobody feels like cooking. The pizzas come loaded with toppings on a soft, slightly chewy crust, and the square-cut trays travel well. It is an ideal option if you are already running errands along Route 82 and want to swing by for takeout on your way back to the village.
05
Best quick stop over the line
Pizza Joe's
Near Greenville, Pa • Regional Chain Pizzeria With Counter Service • Convenient Border-Town Option
A fast, familiar choice just across the state line with plenty of slice and tray options.
If you do much driving into western Pennsylvania, Pizza Joe's makes an easy stop for a casual pie or a quick box to take home. The menu covers classic pepperoni-and-cheese, specialty combinations, and party-cut square trays that suit game nights or small gatherings. It is not fancy, but the consistent pies and convenient locations make it a practical choice for Orangeville folks crossing the border.