01
Best overall pick
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders
Navarre Avenue Strip • Lively Pizzeria And Grinder Shop • Local Favorite
A go-to Oregon stop for big, cheesy pies and hefty grinder sandwiches in a laid-back setting.
Mancino's anchors the Navarre Avenue corridor for many locals thanks to its consistently crisp crust and generous toppings. The menu ranges from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pizzas, plus the namesake grinders that make it easy to please a mixed group. It’s an easy choice when you want a reliable pizza night without driving into downtown Toledo.
02
Best for delivery night
Bambino's Pizza & Subs
Residential Oregon Near Navarre • Casual Delivery And Takeout Shop • Neighborhood Standby
A classic neighborhood joint known for hearty pizzas, toasted subs, and fast, friendly delivery around Oregon.
Bambino's leans into comfort food, with thick layers of cheese, well-seasoned sauce, and a crust that holds up on the ride home. Their subs and appetizers make it easy to round out a game-day spread or a movie night in. It’s the kind of place regulars keep on speed dial when they want familiar flavors done right.
03
Best for late-night cravings
Vito's Pizza
Near Coy Road • Regional Chain Pizzeria • Dependable Carryout Choice
A regional favorite offering loaded specialty pies, wings, and breadsticks that hit the spot after a long day.
Vito's brings a bit of Toledo’s pizza culture into Oregon with its hefty toppings and crowd-pleasing specialty combinations. The crust is substantial without being too doughy, making it great for sharing platters with friends or coworkers. With wings, breadsticks, and sauces to mix and match, it works well for bigger groups and casual hangouts.
04
Most consistent chain pick
Marco's Pizza
Starr Avenue Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Reliable Weeknight Option
A familiar Marco's outpost turning out well-balanced pies with a savory sauce and plenty of customization.
This Starr Avenue Marco's is popular with families for its predictable quality and frequent specials. The dough has a pleasant chew, and their signature sauce leans savory, which pairs well with classic toppings like sausage and green peppers. It’s ideal when you need something quick, consistent, and close by after school or work.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Arturo's Pizza Kitchen
Across The River In Northwood • Old-School Pizza And Cheese Bread Shop • Best For Cheese Lovers
A longtime local favorite just south of Oregon, famous for its cheesy pies, oven-baked subs, and trademark cheese bread.
Arturo's sits a short drive from Oregon on Oregon Road and rewards the trip with rich, cheese-forward pizzas and a retro takeout vibe. Many regulars swear by the cheese bread and baked subs as much as the pies themselves, making it easy to build a full meal from one counter. If you’re exploring beyond Oregon’s city limits, this is a smart first stop.