01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Downtown Orrville • Neighborhood Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Hearty Pies
Generous toppings, a chewy golden crust, and fair prices make Gionino’s the go-to pizza stop for many Orrville families.
If you like a substantial, Midwest-style pie, Gionino’s checks all the boxes with thick cheese coverage, a slightly sweet sauce, and plenty of topping combos. The square-cut pizzas travel well, making this an easy choice for takeout on busy weeknights. Expect a steady stream of locals picking up orders, especially on Friday and game days.
02
Chain comfort pick
Pizza Hut
West High Street Corridor • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For Familiar Favorites
This Orrville Pizza Hut delivers the pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and wings you already know, with easy dine-in, carryout, and delivery options.
When you want exactly what you expect from a national chain, this spot delivers that comfort factor, from classic pepperoni to loaded supreme pies. It’s a practical stop for families, with kid-friendly menus and straightforward combo deals. Order ahead for carryout on busy nights, as the parking lot fills quickly around dinner.
03
Fast delivery pick
Domino's Pizza
North Orrville Near Route 57 • National Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Quick Delivery And Deals
Domino’s in Orrville is all about speed, late hours, and constant coupons, making it an easy choice when you need pizza in a hurry.
This is the spot locals lean on for last-minute dinners, late study sessions, and impromptu watch parties. Build-your-own pizzas, specialty pies, and sides like cheesy bread give you plenty to mix and match, usually with a promo code to soften the bill. It’s not a linger-and-dine kind of place, but for hot pizza at your door with reliable timing, it does the job.
04
Worth-the-drive destination
Coccia House
Wooster Side-Street Location • Old-School Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For A Lingering Pizza Night Out
Coccia House is a beloved Wooster institution known for its hefty, cheese-loaded pies that feel straight out of a 1960s family parlor.
Expect a cozy, no-frills dining room, pizzas heavy on cheese, and a crust that’s substantial enough to support serious toppings. It’s the kind of place where people don’t mind waiting a bit because the pies come out piping hot and built to share. If you’re making the drive from Orrville, plan on a relaxed dinner rather than a quick in-and-out stop.
05
Thin-crust crowd-pleaser
Donatos Pizza
Wooster Shopping Corridor • Ohio-Based Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Crispy Edge-To-Edge Toppings
Donatos in Wooster serves the brand’s signature ultra-thin crust pizzas with toppings spread right to the edge for maximum crunch in every bite.
This is a smart choice when your group leans toward lighter, crispier pies instead of thick, doughy slices. The edge-to-edge topping style means every square-cut piece pulls its weight, which works well for parties and office orders. Round it out with salads and subs and you’ve got an easy all-in-one meal for a mixed crowd.